MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

Oh sure, muck up a pretty decent device with garbage advertising.

They tried that with iTunes too.

But just look at all the millions and billions Google is pulling in from ad revenue....

...makes you wonder...slow economic times...slowing hardware sales...

Of course AT&T;will want a cut...zzz

Oct 09, 08 - 09:15 am Comment from: Jamie

Fsck advertising, I'd rather pay for the App than have to endure advertising on my iPhone.

I've bought quite a few Apps because advertising crept in to the 'Lite' versions of the same App.

Death to advertising!!!!!!!

Oct 09, 08 - 09:41 am Comment from: Jay-Z

I deleted the NY Times app because it had advertising, and I don't keep any apps that have it. I don't need or want advertising wasting screen space and EDGE bandwidth. Apple customers tend to be at the higher end of the income spectrum, and I'd imagine most of us are willing to pay a little more not to deal with the hassle.

Oct 09, 08 - 09:54 am Comment from: Macdoc

I delete Pandora because the update included a BestBuy Ad LoGo.
Screw that...

Thanks for the information. Now I will never have Tap Tap Revenge or Pandora Radio on my touch.

Oct 09, 08 - 10:05 am Comment from: PBIPhotobug

Article says: "the iPhone's touchscreen, built-in GPS and other features dish up more relevant ads. For example, iPhone owners might tap a banner ad for a restaurant that's near their current location and it could provide turn-by-turn directions,"

I keep my iPhone Location Services turned off except when **I** want it to be used. I hope Apple is smart enough to respect user preferences such as this and only let these viral apps use services the user has specifically authorized them to use, and only at those times the user has authorized.

I think I speak for a lot of people when I say that we don't any durn ads on our iPhones!

Oct 09, 08 - 10:13 am Comment from: Predrag

Clearly, nine out of ten iPhone owners prefer free over paid. It is possible that out of those nine, a few more would pay if that meant getting rid of the ads, if, in the future, those ads become prevalent in those free apps. Still, it is more than likely that even among the affluent Apple users, free will have strong appeal, ads or not.

If DVD movies were free with imbedded ads, I'd get them, rip them and splice them together without the ads.

I work for an advertising agency so maybe my perspective doesn't count. I agree that advertsing can suck. On the other hand it can enable certain valuable apps to exist that would otherwise not.

Oct 09, 08 - 10:30 am Comment from: alansky

You mean "Ad industry greedily eyes Apple iPhone..."

All I have to say is: Over my dead body!!!

Bubblewrap now has ads, so I'm not updating the bubblewrap app. if it gets to the point where it won't work due to some iPhone update, I'll just delete it.

The thing that really annoyed me was for that app, under the "What's New" section, the author conveniently omitted the fact that it now has ads. If app authors decide to put ads in their apps, they should fully disclose it in the What's New section.

Maybe keeping advertising off the iPhone/touch is one reason why Apple wants to "approve" of App Store apps?

Oh yes, puhleeez. Support AdBusters mag and start a world campaign to end intrusive advertising. Only the feeble-minded will fall for the ad man's lying blurb. Ads add cost to everything you buy and they interrupt your enjoyment of movies and tv and more. Disagree? Then look forward to ads and billboards all over your sensescape and multiple kinds of sell noise that become the unending, inescapable soundtrack to your life. If you think you might look forward to all that noise, you really should get out more and make friends with your Self and get some signal into your life. If you get no signals, of course you will crave any noise.

the iPhone's touchscreen, built-in GPS and other features dish up more relevant ads. For example, iPhone owners might tap a banner ad for a restaurant that's near their current location and it could provide turn-by-turn directions

Bad idea.

Do we really want "STOP HERE NOW!" popup ads from every business in an iPhone's range? Hell no.

If I need something I'll do a locate. I don't need popups to "help" with that.

How about a free iAds app, that's nothing but advertising?

I don't mind a tiny non-flashing, unchanging teeny weeny little ad on free games and novelties so long as it doesn't affect app performance. However, any app that adds obnoxious flashing or slideshowy ginormous garbage will be deleted -- especially if it's an app that does something useful, like a to-do list or some such.


That said, I want an AdBlocker equivalent for iPhone Safari as soon as possible. The ads and unnecessary graphics kill the load time on alot of pages I visit (Edge).

I will go absolutely ballistic if I'm walking along and my phone chimes with some popup ad of a nearby store or anything like that. That kind of crap should be banned by Apple. If not banned, it should be an "Opt-In" only function. Period.

"[...] iPhone owners might tap a banner ad for a restaurant that's near their current location and it could provide turn-by-turn directions."

This is a great idea, if I'm actually interested in having something to eat. It's not a great idea if I'm just walking around the area.

Advertising must be pull--I'm interested in food, so give me a list of restaurants. If it's push--here's a list of restaurants, just in case you're interested in food--I'll be annoyed by it.

"...such as popular mobile game Tap Tap Revenge and Pandora Radio... are already experimenting with ads. Play a round of Tap Tap, for instance, and you'll likely see a banner ad for Jaguar cars on the bottom of your screen. Both Best Buy and Beck's have signed up to insert ads on Pandora's mobile application."

Thanks for the info. Now I know what apps to avoid. Fsckers.

The App Store should clearly indicate whether an app is ad supported.

Oct 09, 08 - 08:07 pm Comment from: mreposter

I could see restaurants creating simple online ordering apps. It'll store your preferred location so that you can quickly place your order and do a pick up and go on the way home from work.

Oct 09, 08 - 08:22 pm Comment from: bobchr

Anyone who is familiar with Google Earth and the Google maps application on the Iphone must know that this has been embedded in the app from the start. I think what most people are objecting to are pop up when you're not looking for a business or service but just looking for directions or trying to complete a specific task. If I punch in Motel 6 or Dairy Queen, I find that the choices given to me sometimes go beyond what I requested, like Super 8 or Day's Inn or Cold Stone Creamery. I generally don't mind this as long as it gives me an exhaustive list of the specific choices I asked for. But viral pop up ad's I think we can all do without.

although i agree with most of you, what you say is extremely ironic.



This website is BOMBARDED with ads. Can't you idiots see? Why don't you just boycott this site if you hate ads so much?