MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

 MacDailyNews Poll

Deal of the Day

5 Day Most Commented

Opinion Archive

Current Headlines

Latest Joy of Tech

  • Latest Joy of Tech!

MacNN

AppleInsider

Macworld UK

TUAW

MacRumors

Yahoo! Finance AAPL

iTunes Top 10 Albums

Mac OS X Downloads

Sun, Nov 08, 2009 - 02:08 AM EST  —  AAPL: 194.34 (+0.3099, +0.16%)  |  NASDAQ: 2112.44 (+7.12, +0.34%)

Bill Gates jokes about Mac OS X ‘Tiger’ and calls Apple ‘the super-small market share guy’
Monday, May 02, 2005 - 11:01 PM EST

"The Microsoft chairman [Bill Gates] drew guffaws [at a meeting of business journalists on Monday] when he took a dig at Apple Computer Inc. in response to questions about the rave reviews the competitor's newest operating system, Mac OS X 'Tiger,' received upon release last week," Frank Bajak reports for The Associated Press

"The overwhelming consensus was that Tiger was far and away the best consumer operating system available now, with Microsoft not expected to match it in features in Windows until the end of 2006 at the earliest in its 'Longhorn' system," Bajak reports. "Gates said he was pleased that the media were getting excited about computer operating systems. And then he took his jab at Apple, whose share of the consumer market is nearly 4 percent. 'You can always tell if you're working on a Mac or a PC. Just take your applications and stick them in there and see if they run,' he said, moments after calling Apple 'the super-small market share guy.'"

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: "You can always tell if you're working on a Mac or a PC. Just take your applications and stick them in there and see if they run." Gates is correct. If it crashes and blue-screens, it's a Windows PC. If it runs and just works, it's a Mac.

Market share, folks, that's all they have. It's all they've ever had over the Mac. By the way, there are 18,456 Macintosh-specific software items in Apple's Macintosh Product Guide. What Gates neglects to mention, of course, is that Apple's Mac OS X Tiger operating system, iMovie, iDVD, iPhoto, iChat AV, Safari, GarageBand, and many other award-winning, best-in-class applications don't run on Windows PCs. Perhaps Apple Mac users should decide not to stick Microsoft software in their Macs anymore? Hey, we've got an idea, why doesn't Gates stick Longhorn in his PC and see if it runs? Oh yeah, that's right, it doesn't exist.

Gates has the odor of fear about him. It's not about money, it's about winning with Gates and Jobs. And it's Jobs who's destined to win, not Gates. History rewards the originals, the innovators, those who strive for excellence; not the fakes, the copiers, and those who roll up sales with mediocre products to a confused, technophobic public. People are waking up. Personal computing is emerging from infancy and the public is becoming more educated and discerning. Sometime in the not-so-distant future, the world will look back at the fact that Microsoft Windows once held 95% market share for computer operating systems and more than just mere guffaws will be heard.

Advertisement: Get your own thick, white tagless t-shirt stating, Bill Gates is stuck using a Dell running Windows XP and listening to Napster To Go on an iRiver. There is a God. In crisp black Myriad Pro text. Available in Small, Medium, Large, X-large, 2X, 3X, and 4X-large. Just $18.99. Thank you for supporting MacDailyNews.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Mac users should not buy Microsoft software - May 16, 2003

BusinessWeek: 'Tiger bolsters Mac OS X's edge as the best personal-computer operating system around' - April 28, 2005
Associated Press: Mac OS X Tiger 'provides another excellent incentive to switch from Windows' - April 28, 2005
Mossberg: Apple's Tiger 'the best, most advanced personal computer operating system on the market' - April 28, 2005
NY Times: Apple's Mac OS X Tiger is the most secure, stable and satisfying OS on earth - April 28, 2005
Bill Gates: Microsoft's 'responsible for the creation of the PC industry' - February 18, 2005
Experts say Bill Gates' doodles show he's 'stressed and tense, not a natural leader' (with image) - January 31, 2005
Windows blue screen of death crashes Gates' Keynote at CES - January 06, 2005
Even Bill Gates can't avoid Windows malware; Mac users surf the Web freely - October 03, 2004
Bill Gates' sarcasm regarding Apple iPod: 'Oh, wow, I don't think we can do that' - September 07, 2004
Bill Gates on Apple's 'Keynote' app: 'I doubt what they've done is as rich as PowerPoint' - January 09, 2003

Bookmark and Share

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Reader Feedback: = registered.
Unregistered users: Feedback from multiple usernames are subject to deletion. Off-topic and posts from suspected astroturfers will be removed.

May 02, 05 - 09:41 pm Comment from: df

For him to even comment, especially something like that, is smalllllllllllll

May 02, 05 - 09:46 pm Comment from: Tony

The most envy and rich dumb ass in the world ... guess ........

May 02, 05 - 09:46 pm Comment from: Sean Tham

Who's Bill Gates? Is it a type of food?

May 02, 05 - 09:52 pm Comment from: BuriedCaesar

Yup - bad form in any PR/media situation to react to questions about how a competitor is being perceived with anything other than with something about your own product. Just adds fuel to the fire of the competitor. In this case, it's a good thing, because little Billy got caught with his guard down. This'll come back to haunt him in about 18 months from now, assuming the timing doesn't change... smirk

May 02, 05 - 09:55 pm Comment from: lenzcap

MDN, you really crack me up somtimes. Keep it up.

May 02, 05 - 09:57 pm Comment from: threeandahalf

Just take your virus and stick it in there and see if it runs...

May 02, 05 - 10:00 pm Comment from: dennis

That's so funny I forgot to guffaw.

May 02, 05 - 10:01 pm Comment from: bisabuelo

Um, is it just me that realizes that what gates said is actually more or less true? First of all, the majority of applications DON'T run on apples. The crucial ones usually run on both, but there are many that do not. The number of software titles that run on apple but not on PCs is much smaller (mainly first party apps). Second, apple IS the super small market share guy. I don't see the second comment as particularly negative; it's just the truth.

May 02, 05 - 10:06 pm Comment from: Hoo_R_U_kidding

Funny, I thought the super small market share guy only had 2% market share less than 6 months ago. Now it's 4% and gaining fast!

May 02, 05 - 10:11 pm Comment from: Mac User

"the super-small market share guy."

Is this Bill's way of saying to Steve: "Come on Steve, lets have a real dog fight here. Your making great products that most people seem to ignore (iPod being the exception). You're not agressive enough Steve. When I come out with Longhorn I won't be fooling around. Most people don't want to buy an Apple computer, they want to run Windows. You can't hide from the numbers Steve. Is the iPod going to be the last great thing Apple does?"

May 02, 05 - 10:12 pm Comment from: Wow, not only is he scared

but he's letting it show!

Amazing times.

And I guess he should be scared, if awareness of OS X has gotten so good that the issue came up at all!

Not scared for 2005... but for 2010? Terrified.

May 02, 05 - 10:13 pm Comment from: Testing

Yeah... I'm on a Mac and all my applications run....
My friends on Windows are always returning software because it will not run on their systems...

May 02, 05 - 10:14 pm Comment from: Keith

It's really strange that he even commented on Apple. Also, bigger is not always better.

FYI, there are a lot of crappy Windows based applications that don't work very well on a Wintel box.

May 02, 05 - 10:15 pm Comment from: mike

Well, Steve has been talking smack for a while.. and Windows is open architecture.. so there's your marketshare... I'm pretty sure, later on in the interview, Gates talked about all the money they're making of Mac Office 2004

http://www.gizmodo.com/gadgets//gates-interview-part-two-windows-postlonghorn-and-apples-office-suite-029272.php

I wonder what it feels like to be constantly fighting with your customers, developing new ways to get them to 'upgrade' to a 4 year old OS, as the vast vast majority of Windows users are still content to write essays and check email on WIn 98 or 2000.

To see Mac users lining up all around the world, must be puzzling, after all.. Apple doesn't even write software, do they? I thought they were the iPod Company... wink

May 02, 05 - 10:18 pm Comment from: LordRobin

"Applications"? Hmm... I seem to remember those things. Weren't they important back in the days before open standards, before everything ran everywhere?

Okay... We're not there yet. But that's the way the tide is turning.

May 02, 05 - 10:18 pm Comment from: Triumph

"Super-small". Yeh-hesss.

Listen, I've seen Bill Gates in de locker room. This guy shouldn't be talking about "small". Know what I mean?

"Micro"? "Soft"? "Super-SMALL"? Hey, I keed, but I'm beginning to see a pattern. No seriously -- Bill is "small" enough . . .

. . . for me to POOP on!!!!

May 02, 05 - 10:25 pm Comment from: Don.

Now if only he would allow himself to watch The Incredibles (You KNOW it's good Bill) maybe he could learn a little bit from Syndrome.

May 02, 05 - 10:25 pm Comment from: Majikthize

"You can always tell if you're working on a Mac or a PC. Just take your applications and stick them in there and see if they run."

I guess all Bill's apps are on floppies. Nice to know, though, that he's still trying to stuff them into Macs.

May 02, 05 - 10:29 pm Comment from: Insider

Apple is currently working on Windows versions of the iLife software suite. They will hold off selling iLife for Windows until Longhorn is released to see if their market share has risen significantly or not. If market share has not increased enough, iLife for Windows will go on sale. Special academic discounts will be made for schools who will be the biggest users of these digital media apps including GarageBand. iLife for Windows will be the next big thing from Apple. Apple will no longer ignore the 10's of millions of Windows users who will have decided by the time Longhorn ships whether they will buy a Mac or not. Apple will expand the "Apple on Windows" experience and reap the rewards they justly deserve.

May 02, 05 - 10:49 pm Comment from: Bubba

Slowwwwwwwwwwwww news day MDN?

May 02, 05 - 10:54 pm Comment from: Super Insider

Insider,

If Mac market share isn't satisfactory, Jobs won't do small potatoes as you describe. He'll drop the X-bomb on Bill. Mac OS X for x86. Let's see if Gates finds that funny.

May 02, 05 - 11:02 pm Comment from: mike

how 'small market share guy...just stick in apps to see if they run' drew uproarious laughter from the journalists is beyond comprehension.

Unless he was handing out wads of money while he was talking..

bill, your jokes were lame in high school; they're lame now

May 02, 05 - 11:08 pm Comment from: Josh VH

oooh blah. Yeah, maybe on a mac you can ONLY find 1-5 GREAT applications for everything you need, namely the iLife suite, Final Cut Pro, etc.... Lets say that yeah, I only have 20 Apps (all apple software + Office + Photoshop etc...) I would rather have 20 GREAT apps than the 100,000 crappy ones available for windows. The only reason they have so many apps is because there arent any great ones that stand out. Im buying a t-shirt btw!

May 02, 05 - 11:24 pm Comment from: Jon shand

Lucky for me I don't use any Microsoft software. At least Apple and Steve Jobs live in the real world and the Mac OS works and dosen't look like it should be put in a Museum.

May 02, 05 - 11:34 pm Comment from: MacMania

It's kind of pathetic that the "richest man" in the world is so poor in the things that should matter. What a character!

Wish he had something more Earth shattering and inspiring to say to a crowd than his typical derogatory bullshit.

BTW, their recent quarterly profit was way above Wall Street expectations. When you collect a 'cpu tax' from 90%+ of computer users and don't improve your crap for 7 years, you tend to break profit records. You go Bill!

May 03, 05 - 12:02 am Comment from: Chuch

"You can always tell if you're working on a Mac or a PC. Just take your applications and stick them in there and see if they run."


Bill has a pretty good test here. It has been my experience that things work on a mac... In the PC (windows) world things crash all the time and if they do work, don't do it well.

If I want some frustration I can run windows apps in VPC ... if I want to feel like a real geek, I can boot up in Linux. If I want to work, I use Tiger... Hum...

Yulp... Bill you got this one right. It is not a very good advert for the Windows computer market... but you got it right.

May 03, 05 - 12:15 am Comment from: bikersrule

This is just tit for tat. Jobs makes fun of Gates and Windows, then the latter returns fire and has a go at the former and Apple. Boring stuff.

Let's see what can I do that's more interesting…I know what I'll do I'll go to sleep. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ.

(Several hours later.)

Oh one our nationals was just kidnapped by some Iraqis; now that got my attention.

May 03, 05 - 01:01 am Comment from: Viridian

"Um, is it just me that realizes that what gates said is actually more or less true? First of all, the majority of applications DON'T run on apples."

Bisabuelo,

First of all it's "Macs", not "apples", and I presume that you're including malware, adware and spyware in the "majority of applications" to which you refer. If not, you should, and I for one am damned glad that they don't run on Macs.

May 03, 05 - 01:04 am Comment from: Eric

Maybe if he'd finished Harvard the guy would be able to speak like a literate person? Could be!

May 03, 05 - 01:08 am Comment from: Viridian

And as for Gates' comments, so what? He has to say something to show that he's not concerned with Tiger possibly damaging Longhorn's chances in the market. It's called "whistling in the dark." The sense I get, what with the baffling marketing campaign around WinXP, is that Microsoft is in full damage control mode. I do feel a smidgen of an iota of sympathy for them, but only an idiot would discount Microsoft's marketing prowess. These people could sell porn mags to a blind man.

May 03, 05 - 01:10 am Comment from: iPodder

On my Mac I can run OS X applications AND UNIX applications. Sorry Windowers, that makes for a LOT MORE of the whole lot of crappy Windows only stuff you can put on your floppies.

Gates is rich but rather ignorant. He still does not get that OS X is Unix and the ballpark of applications that can run on OS X just puny the little number (relatively speaking) of sw titles on Windows.

May 03, 05 - 01:23 am Comment from: ndelc

Was that his best attempt at being funny? Wow, that's sad. The first time I read it, I thought, "Wow, he just paid Apple a big compliment saying that things just work on a Mac as opposed to his crappy OS." After a few more times I got it. Uhh, good one Bill.

May 03, 05 - 01:24 am Comment from: G Spank

Don, that was spot on! (Now if only he would allow himself to watch The Incredibles (You KNOW it's good Bill) maybe he could learn a little bit from Syndrome.)

Bubba, what is your problem?

Bill Gates, you are starting to crack my man, and what's on the inside ain't pretty.

May 03, 05 - 01:27 am Comment from: ndelc

And another thing: "The overwhelming consensus was that Tiger was far and away the best consumer operating system available now, with Microsoft not expected to match it in features in Windows until the end of 2006 at the earliest in its 'Longhorn' system," Bajak reports."

I think people are being very generous saying that Longhorn will "match" Tiger when (if) it comes out. They may share a COUPLE of similar features (if Longhorn ever sees the light of day) but, let's not forget, it's still gonna be Windows. I mean come on. You can put a cat in the oven, but that don't make it a biscuit.

May 03, 05 - 01:40 am Comment from: Charko

Insider,

I agree with you there. S.Jobs tends to be cautious in such matters - and with good reason. It'll probably be iLife before OS X.

May 03, 05 - 01:49 am Comment from: DreamTheEndless

MDN Take = :D

May 03, 05 - 02:34 am Comment from: spinaltap

In a world without fences and walls, who needs Gates and Windows?

-----------------------
My Mac can go all the way up to XI

May 03, 05 - 03:19 am Comment from: Henry

The M$ response to everything these days seems to be, "yes, but we have market share".

Apple has a superior OS = yes, but we have market share
Windows full of viruses = yes, but we have market share
Windows a pile of crap = yes, but we have market share

Not really compelling arguments to stay with the Windows platform going forward .... Gates sounds hassled. Clearly Tiger superiorty has got to him. Excellent.

May 03, 05 - 04:22 am Comment from: MCCFR

Two ways of looking at this…

As a platform, the overall marketshare for MacOS on a quarter by quarter basis is relatively small. However these numbers aren't subtle enough to show two things, a) how many Macintosh systems are actually installed and running and b) how many user/choosers choose MacOS over Windows.

The former is important, because Wintel sales are distorted by an inferior obsolescence record which leads to more Wintel boxes being used for landfill quicker than their Macintosh contemporaries, and the latter is important because Wintel sales are further distorted by the 'herd' mentality in business that - for reasons passing understanding - says that nobody ever got fired for buying Windows.

And the other perspective is that, as a manufacturer, Apple was only marginally behind IBM (50,000 units) in US unit shipments in the last quarter, and - with the success of the Mac mini - there is every possibility that Apple could break into the number 4 position before the end of the year. If Apple land up finishing the year as a bigger manufacturer than IBM and possibly Gateway, Bill's comment is going to come back and bite him in the ass.

May 03, 05 - 04:35 am Comment from: A new Mac user

Re:

Um, is it just me that realizes that what gates said is actually more or less true? First of all, the majority of applications DON'T run on apples. The crucial ones usually run on both, but there are many that do not. The number of software titles that run on apple but not on PCs is much smaller (mainly first party apps). Second, apple IS the super small market share guy. I don't see the second comment as particularly negative; it's just the truth.


I COULD SAY THAT YOU TRY AND STICK A WINDOWS APP ON A MAC AND IT WONT WORK.

BILL'S STATEMENT APPLIES TO BOTH OS's.

May 03, 05 - 06:19 am Comment from: John Crawford

Pop-unders seem to have disappeared with Tiger, but I now have irritating audio clips playing each time I tab to MDN.

What's going on? And I have checked that it's not Bill G.

John

MW = Medical. Do I need one or what?

May 03, 05 - 06:44 am Comment from: Snugfig

You can always tell that you are working on a PC or a Mac by counting the number of times the computer:
- crashes
- is infected by a virus
- doesn't do what you commanded it to do
- has to be taken into a "geek squad" center to have it serviced in the previous 3 months
- has to have the OS re-installed to get your computer up and running again
- displays an alert window asking you to upgrade
- displays an alert window warning you of a possible security risk when doing anything with your computer.
- displays an alert window asking you to purchase something
- prompts you to ask "what the f#$k?!"
- forces you to pound your desk in frustration
- raises your blood pressure simply by using it

Note 1: Notice how MS has decided to use IBM PowerPC chip in their new version of the XBox gaming console. Hmmm, the same chips that have powered EVERY Macintosh computer made since 1994.

Note 2: Have you noticed the new MS "START" Windows XP tv ads that prompt you to purchase software that runs on Windows which strangely is promoting what? A new version of Windows XP? No! A new peice of hardware? No!

Some company should create their own ads that ask viewers to choose a platform that simply "STARTS" and "WORKS" the way you want it to.

Can you smell the fear out in Redmond?

Enjoy,
Dan

Keyword: Value, as in value something that actually works!

May 03, 05 - 06:54 am Comment from: Glick7

My company dumped its last Windows PC a few months ago, and is an "all Mac" business now. We purchased our first Mac OSx machine in March, 2002 and have not looked back since.

The vast majority of our clients still run Windows, and we have no problems doing business with them and exchanging files.

Our first OSx machine - an original 800mhz flat screen iMac - has been purring away for over three years now with no trouble, no data loss, no viruses and never even a re-boot needed.

All our other Macs are just as solid.

We never have any downtime. It's like a dream come true for those of us who used to spend hours and hours and hours babysitting the vulnerable and unstable Windows systems.

Apple Mac OSx. It just works.

Thank you, Apple.

May 03, 05 - 07:17 am Comment from: mike

Note 2: Have you noticed the new MS "START" Windows XP tv ads that prompt you to purchase software that runs on Windows which strangely is promoting what? A new version of Windows XP?

Yup. For most people... XP is new. Most people are still hanging out in Win98 land with the almighty teal green background. The only reason new features are added to XP at all (SP2) is to encourage people to actually get Windows XP...

May 03, 05 - 07:26 am Comment from: mike

I was trying to think of something witty to say, but then I realized how many people I know who are totally sick of Windows and are passing around copies of Linux.

BTW, they don't miss Clippy.

May 03, 05 - 07:29 am Comment from: MIke D'L B Simoni

Market Share - Market Share - Market Share....

I fail to see how a ton of manure is more valuable than a pound of gold.

May 03, 05 - 07:32 am Comment from: matty g

mccfr -

which would explain how online stats show mac's have 15% of the market share


brought to by the magic word ahead ie apple's ahead of the times as always

May 03, 05 - 07:33 am Comment from: SpicemustFlow

Yes, it's true. Bill saw the real problem of Apple... sorry, but it's true!

Mac guy's since 1984

May 03, 05 - 07:38 am Comment from: Dave H

John Crawford

Scroll down. It's that super-annoying advert for mobile ringtones. For some reason, it briefly plays to show its loaded, then waits for your mouse pointer to cross it before playing again.

I think this is a "feature" of the more-compatible Safari, since I don't get that ad at all on the machine I've left running Panther.

May 03, 05 - 07:42 am Comment from: Newmanstein

What about the end user, Bill?? Huh? Is marketshare so important that you forgot about the end user and their experience using your crap?

Why are you even commenting about 4% if so tiny a market share is not important?? I'll tell you why...it's because Apple's 4% has kicked
your pretend technology asses up and down for years and years.
You lie awake at night and think about it...it haunts you every day...you will never have any satisfaction with Apple beating you to the punch each and every day. What else can you possibly say anymore except for market share?? All the misconceptions have been put out to pasture where the Longhorns graze.

May 03, 05 - 07:44 am Comment from: Dave H

BTW, the Apple Store's down. New iMacs today perhaps?

Reader feedback page 1 of 3 pages:  1 2 3 >

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Add Your Feedback:

Register or Login