Dubious lawsuit targets Apple iPhone battery

“The iPhone has only been out for a month, yet there’s already a class-action lawsuit against it over its battery life,” Ed Oswald reports for BetaNews.

“Jose Trujillo filed the suit in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois. Among other things, he claims that the battery can only be charged for 300 cycles before needing to be replaced, and that he wasn’t made aware that the battery was soldered inside of the unit,” Oswald reports.

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Note: Apple.com’s iPhone tech specs have stated “built-in rechargeable lithium ion battery” since its preview introduction in January 2007. In addition, Apple.com’s iPhone batteries page – which went live before iPhone went on sale – states, “A properly maintained iPhone battery is designed to retain up to 80% of its original capacity at 400 full charge and discharge cycles.” In additon, Apple.com states (and has stated before iPhone went on sale) that iPhone “offers up to 8 hours of talk time 6 hours of Internet use, 7 hours of video playback, or 24 hours of audio playback on a full charge at original capacity. In addition, iPhone features up to 250 hours of standby time.”

Apple’s iPhone box clearly states on the label, “Battery has limited recharge cycles and may eventually need to be replaced by Apple service provider. Battery life and charge cycles vary by use and settings. See www.apple.com/batteries.

Apple iPhone’s one-year warranty includes replacement coverage for a defective battery. You can extend your coverage to two years from the date of your iPhone purchase with the AppleCare Protection Plan for iPhone. During the plan’s coverage period, Apple will replace the battery if it drops below 50% of its original capacity. If it is out of warranty, Apple offers a battery replacement for $79, plus $6.95 shipping, subject to local tax. Apple offers AppleCare Service iPhones for us for up to 5 days while iPhones undergo battery replacement. The service fee for the AppleCare Service iPhone is $29. iPhone owners just drop their iPhone’s SIM card into the loaner iPhone while the battery is being replaced.

Any judge or lawyer has already long since stopped reading due to fits of uncontrollable, shaking laughter. If you are still able to read this far, it’s likely that your name is either Jose or you are an ambulance chaser with a client named Jose. Either way, you seem to have absolutely no idea how the U.S. legal system works, but at least you have an ample supply of frivolity.

45 Comments

  1. Jose “FUD” Balmer? The idea of the suit was not even to make it into court with such allegations but to put the headline out there. Isn’t there a law against filing spurious claims? Or is that why someone named Jose – possibly litigation-proof – was chosen to “file the suit”? (my son-in-law-to-be is a Puerto Rican, not poor, speaks both English and Spanish fluently, and is a Sys Admin – no racial bias here)

    DLMeyer – the Voice of G.L.Horton’s Stage Page Pod-Cast – now discussing the ICWP Retreat

  2. Charko, what performance issues are you having? My Mac is performing just fine today…

    Oh, you mean STOCK performance! Doubt it’s due to this lawsuit. It isn’t strong enough to merit any movement in pps. Probably just some people taking profits from the past few weeks.

  3. What a country we live in. This is the stupidest thing I have ever seen. By the time my battery stops working on this IPhone I will probably be ready to buy a newer version anyway.

  4. Good!

    Apple should have made a user replaceable battery. Even if it’s a Apple only battery, at least let people extend the life of their product and get value for their hard earned money.

    But NOOOO! Apple solders the dam thing to the mobo and then charges a fortune to replace it and the IT guys get a chance to snoop in on people’s information. Not to mention being without a phone all that time, mail damage etc.

    I’m a big Apple fan, but sometimes the things they do they absolutely deserve to be sued out of their collective asses.

    If Apple expects people to turn over their iPhones every few years they got another thing coming. People will default to the cheap free phones instead.

  5. I sincerely thank Mr Bush for his tort reform.

    Oh, wait. That just prevented poor people from declaring bankruptcy, it didn’t slow down ridiculous, frivolous class-action crap that just lines the large law firms (aka “donors”) pockets at the expense of the buying public.

  6. <<This is the stupidest thing I have ever seen.>>

    Not as stupid as soldering in the battery. Don’t get me wrong- I luv my iPhone- It’s like holding the future. But Apple missed on the battery. It should have had a socket connection- just like my ipod and my wife’s iPod- which I replaced with a $39.00 kit. I’m not asking for a removable battery on the exterior- but at least a way for DIYers to do their own replacements- again- just like the iPod.

    To be honest- If I knew about the soldered in battery- I still would have bought the thing- I just hate surprises.

  7. The judge should throw this case out of court and fine the plaintiff and his lawyer for tying up the judicial system with such nonsense.
    I’d also recommend that this yahoo spend some of his lawyer’s fees to learn how to read English.

    The best word to define this guy is ” schmuck “.

  8. A class action lawsuit is filed by an individual (or a few people) who seek to be approved for class action status by the court based on the fact that many, many potential plaintiffs will or could file similar suits, and it would be best to settle the matter in one lawsuit rather than thousands. If class action status is awarded, anyone who bought an iPhone would, by default, be included in the lawsuit. An iPhone owner could opt out of the lawsuit, but only by responding to the class action notice which will be sent to him/her.

    That being said, I find this fuss about the iPhone’s battery ridiculous. The 400 cycles refers to completely draining the battery 400 times and then charging it back. And after that, you still have 80% battery life/capacity.

    Very few people will drain their battery fully every day. Most, like myself, use some of the battery, and recharge overnight so they can sync their iPhones as well.

    LUL said, “If Apple expects people to turn over their iPhones every few years they got another thing coming. People will default to the cheap free phones instead.”

    That statement’s just plain silly. People already do that with their laptops, iPods, and other consumer electronic devices. And once someone has an iPhone, they sure aren’t going back to the free phone from AT&T, Verizon, etc. They’ll upgrade to a new iPhone and pass the current one on to a family member who either doesn’t need the full battery life or will get a new battery for $90 and have an iPhone.

    Finally, if I wanted an extra battery for, say, a Moto RAZR, AT&T charges between $17 and $50, depending upon the capacity. And I can’t charge it outside of the phone, so I have to constantly swap batteries.

    Buy a charging phone for your car and stop worrying about your battery.

  9. ROFL!

    If this goes to court then im a Mexican!

    Apple have it covered.

    The guy hasnt even had the iphone long enough to use the 400 charge cycles anyway, so any case is just an obvious scam to leach cash out of Apple.

    But America being what it is, some greedy lawyer will try and get the case to court so that Apple settles out of court and gives the guy some cash.

    The problem with Apple, and everyone knows this now, is that they always settle out of court because they dont want the bad publicity.

    People like this guy makes me sick – people like him should be shot at birth.

  10. Also, unless the guy has been on Mars for the last year, he would have known before buying the damn phone that it’s battery is built-in.

    At least Apple didnt hide the facts, unlike Microsoft, and made them clear for anyone who can understand ‘basic’ english language.

    This case is a joke, anyone who is spending $500 on anything tends to read up on the details before buying the product.

    Maybe thats the problem, the guy has no comprehension of basic language or any ability to understand any form of communication.

  11. “Dubious”? Come on, MDN, that’s way too lenient a term for what this is.

    Frivolous? Check. Insane? Yup. Ridiculous? Certainly.

    I’ll choose to frame this one on the wall, right next to the “Satisfaction Guaranteed” pants lawsuit. And get my darts out.

  12. I have had a Palm Tungsten E and several Pocket PCs none of which had a user replaceable battery. Should I have filed suit? If you don’t like the iPhone and the fact that it doesn’t have a user replaceable battery then don’t buy it. I get tired of these complaints about the phone. Blah Blah Blah it doesn’t have 3G, Blah Blah Blah it cost so much, Blah Blah Blah it’s only on AT & T. If you don’t like it then don’t buy it, it’s very simple.

  13. What lbuschjr said. Plus, if your battery has been discharged to just 50% when you plug back in for a charge, that only counts for a 1/2 charge cycle, not 1. There was really no reason for someone not to have known the battery situation before buying. Regardless of what one thinks of Apple’s design decisions, there is only so much that they can do make potential buyers aware of them. It is up to consumers to research the products that they buy; Apple hid nothing, and that is what needs to be proved for a case like this to have any merit.

    MDN word = “really” As in: Yeah, really!

  14. If Nosey Jose managed to open the iphone to remove the battery and found it soldered, he will have invalidated his warranty since nowhere on the packaging does it say,

    “open the casing & remove the battery”.

    If he was following instructions from that video on the website, then we all know how foolish he is since that was not an Apple video.

    The lawyer who is handling this tort must be laughing! does he get paid in advance by Jose?

  15. @ TMF

    But the packaging didn’t SAY that I should remove the iPhone from my pants before laundering!

    Come to think of it, my pants didn’t say “remove your pants before laundering” so I wonder what would happen if I get myself dry cleaned. I can smell the millions already.

  16. If an average person spends:

    2 hours per day talking on the iPhone
    1.5 hours per day surfing the web

    they will drain the battery in two days. The 400 cycles would therefore last them Two years and two months (approximately). At that point, the battery would still hold 80% of the original charge. That means they would still have another two years before the capacity drops below 50%. This all assuming someone spends over three hours talking or surfing on this thing EVERY DAY! Do you know anyone who has three free hours of leisure time (EVERY DAY) to spend/waste on the phone?

  17. Not to mention that talking two hours on the phone every day means spending equivalent of about 2,500 weekday minutes (unless those two hours are after 9PM). That would probably mean that your replacement battery wouldn’t be the most expensive of your troubles…

  18. @ Banker

    “LUL,
    If US$79 +tax + shipping is a “fortune” to you, then you have my deepest pity, you poor bastard.
    One thing’s for certain: you have no business owning an iPhone.”

    Even the world’s greatest billionaires don’t appreciated being ripped off. Paying $79 + Shipping, and more importantly, losing my cell phone for 3 days is a complete ripoff.

    The battery is a bad design, plain and simple. But it does fit into Apple’s philosophy of continuing to suck money out of the consumer long after the sale…

    All that said, the class action lawsuit is plain silly. When you buy a iPhone, you know it has a sealed battery. If that’s a show stopper for you…………. Don’t buy it.

  19. Thanks Shoeman

    That’s my point exactly, I can easily afford many iPhones, but I realize that I’m the minority and I don’t appreciate others getting ripped off just because the “rich” can afford to wipe their asses with iPhones if they prefer.

    Some of us “rich” were poor working stiffs once, so we know exactly how long it takes to earn $79 or $600. It wasn’t pleasent.

    I can understand the rabid fanboyism, but sometimes it’s absolutely blind to the fact that a USER REMOVEABLE BATTTERY WILL BE GOOD FOR THEM.

    Apple has replaceable hard drives and batteries in their laptops, should be the same concept to expensive iPhones.

    $600 laptops have replaceable batteries…

  20. LUL,

    The craziness of this story is not a matter of whether the battery is OR should be replaceable or not. The point is that there are about a hundred ways for Mr. Trujillo to have known BEFORE he bought his phone that the battery wasn’t replacable. Not to mention that the premise of his suit — that the battery is only good for 300 charge cycles — is a outright, blatant, damnable LIE. This guy is the WORST kind of litigious idiot that there is. He is looking for some kind of windfall lawsuit lottery that is entirely motivated by GREED. And this despite the fact that no one who files a class action lawsuit ever gets rich: only the lawyers do. The “victim” (and it’s really bad when there actually IS a victim) gets hosed. Hosed by what brought on the suit, and then hosed by the lawyers who bring the suit “on the victim’s behalf”. But then here, there is no cause for suit, no validity to ANY of this jackass’s claims, and he’s been convinced by some ambulance chasing lawyer that he’s going to get rich from it. It’s a sickening lawsuit in a system clogged with sickening lawsuits that RUIN the American justice system for people who acutally actually NEED justice.

    I won’t mention that I bought the first gen iPod at $399, have never replaced the battery nor had any problems with it, and before I would have ever needed to change the battery I bought a 3rd gen iPod, then a 5th gen iPod, then an iPhone. In which I can guarantee you I will never, EVER have to replace the damned battery.

  21. “@LorD 1776

    not nearly as aggravating as the 256MB RAM stick soldered into one of the two slots in my iBook. Now THAT just sucks.”

    Yes, and I have 4 iBooks G4’s (Wife, Son, Daughter, and my “Road Warrior”). Mine is an old 800 MHZ that I take on the road with me when I travel. Works great in most of the motels I stay at with WiFi…

    Still, the 800 has ONLY a 128 MEG RAM chip soldered in. According to Apple, it should only be upgradable to 640 MEG. But it works fine with another 1 GIG stick so it doesn’t suck too bad…. (The other 3 are all the 1.42 GIG G4’s varieties which officially support a 1 GIG RAM chip)…

    Still I agree, it’s not the best thought out design..

  22. Different subject sort of. I just used Other World Computing to change my iPod battery. I didn’t want to do it. I sent it via Fedex from my front porch last Thursday. I received it this morning on my front porch. Super fast. Great service. If they do iPhones they would probably do Jose’s for free.

  23. You can bet the design was thought out long and hard. If you want to cram that much functionality and technology in such a small package, you need to make compromises. A soldered in battery takes up a lot less space than a connectorized one with a removable door. As others have said, under normal use the battery won’t need to be replaced for over 2 years- longer than the contract obligation is for. By that time, the phone will most likely be upgraded with the new contract. It is a non issue.

    If the iPhone was bulkier and had an ugly ass door on it for the battery, people would bitch about that too.

    People had the same bitch about the iPod at first. I don’t see it slowly down sales of that device.

  24. Well maybe after MS soldered a web browser to it’s operating software people are a little sensitive.

    Actually with all the battery history (isn’t the iPod battery soldered) with explosions and recalls etc. I am surprised that the lawsuit has waited so long before rearing it’s ugly head. I think they should have started it before the iPhone launch, you know a preemptive lawsuit.

    One spin on it though to watch out for and that is environmental toxicity. Having to send back the battery to the manufacturer is a good idea, it ensures that the battery is properly disposed of.

    For those of you that think I am barking up the wrong tree you might want to try looking at the back of a battery operated radioactive smoke alarm or try to follow the instructions here:

    http://www.firebrigade.act.gov.au/Preparedness/Household_Smoke_Alarms/index.html

    Note the funny talk:

    “Radiation authorities advise that the amount of radiation emitted from these devises is much less than natural background levels.”

    I think perhaps it should read “ONE” of these devices. Even though they say that you can toss them into the bin they later on they state:

    “No more than one smoke detector per bin of rubbish though. This will ensure that smoke detectors are well dispersed in the overall bulk of waste in landfill sites. Bulk disposal by this method is not permitted however – collections of smoke detectors must continue to be treated as radioactive waste.”

    Hmmm collections of smoke detectors, makes you think.

    At any rate, the collection of batteries by the manufacturer so that they can be properly disposed of, is an excellent environmental idea. That should put a lawsuit crimp, that is if it ever comes to see the light of day.

  25. “If the iPhone was bulkier and had an ugly ass door on it for the battery, people would bitch about that too.”

    Well yeah, the fanboys might. Obvious something that is “really beautiful” or “really gorgeous” is what is important to most Apple Fans…

    I on the other hand tend to look at practical features. I can’t think of one other phone on the market that requires that you send it away for 3 days and have to rent a loaner while the battery gets replaced…

    I tend to think of myself as an Apple user, not a drooling fanboy. To say that the inability for the user to change a battery is somehow an advantage is shortsighted at best, and blind fanboyism at worst. For the price they are asking for this thing, it’s missing lots of features. I hope that Apple incorporates additional features in it’s next gen iPhone – features that even the most basic cell phones contain (like the ability of buying a battery and putting it in)…

  26. @Shoeman

    First, how do you use bold and italic tags in your comments? I always feel like I’m yelling when I have to CAPS something when I want to just italicize it. And I’d rather save caps for when I’m actually yelling ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    Second: in this case (non-replaceable batteries) it’s not a matter of fanboy-ness, at least not on my part. Most cell phones have replaceable batteries IMHO because all OTHER cell phones have replaceable batteries, not because they need one. I had a Treo 650 for several years before my iPhone, and the only time I even looked at the battery was when I had to open the back to hit the reset button. It never needed a new battery, and over it’s lifetime probably never would have.

    I have heard of very few users actually having to replace the battery in their iPods. Sure, you hear the squeaky wheels talk about it on the net, but that’s because they are the squeaky wheels. I’ve never heard a single user of an iPod that I personally know have a single issue with their iPod battery. Myself included, and one of my iPods is 5 years old (I bought it almost as soon as it was available). I certainly use my cell phone less than I ever have an iPod, even AS an iPod the iPhone uses flash memory which is less draining on the battery than a hard drive, and the battery technology itself is far better now than five years ago. So what is the point of having a replaceable battery on the iPhone if no one is every going to have to replace one? From a financial standpoint that is just money down the drain for Apple. Yet people were complaining about it before the iPhone was even released. That’s just asinine. It doesn’t NEED a replaceable battery folks. That’s why it doesn’t HAVE one.

  27. Notice how the article starts with the obvious and then idiots confuse Jose’s blatant and dishonest ignorance with their own personal want list?

    Guys, it’s not about what you want.
    It’s about Jose lying through his teeth to make a quick buck.

    I don’t care about what you want. I do care that this scuzzball is misusing the courts for his own gain.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.