MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

 MacDailyNews Poll

Deal of the Day

5 Day Most Commented

Opinion Archive

Current Headlines

Latest Joy of Tech

  • Latest Joy of Tech!

MacNN

AppleInsider

Macworld UK

TUAW

MacRumors

Yahoo! Finance AAPL

iTunes Top 10 Albums

Mac OS X Downloads

Sat, Nov 21, 2009 - 03:49 PM EST  —  AAPL: 199.92 (-0.59, -0.29%)  |  NASDAQ: 2146.04 (-10.78, -0.5%)

Microsoft’s Windows Vista one year later: ‘the chrome has worn off the turd’
Wednesday, January 30, 2008 - 12:00 PM EST

One year after Charlie Demerjian called Microsoft's Windows Vista a "chrome plated turd," he's back to take another look:

"It has been a year since Vista was released, and I said I could not in good conscience go there. Since then, Vista has gotten a thorough airing, has been debated more than anything in recent memory, and for the vast majority, the chrome has worn off the turd," Demerjian writes.

"[A year ago] I lamented the fact that MS was forcing me to use Linux against my will, but Vista was unacceptable to me on far too many grounds," Demerjian writes. "To be honest, MS did try to engage me after I wrote that, but the sad thing is it was through bribery. I don't use that word lightly, but there is nothing else I can call it."

MacDailyNews Note: See the full article for more on the bribery.

Demerjian continues, "So, 12 months to the day after release, Vista is still a chrome plated turd, but due to direct abuses of the customer, much of that chrome has worn off. Activation servers that could never go down did for days."

"Inviolate promises of user control over patching was shown to be far less important than MS needs to control your box, and hosts of other egregious violations show how much MS really cares about the people giving them money," Demerjian writes.

Demerjian writes, "Until MS does a complete 180 on the anti-user aspects of Vista, it remains unsuitable for use to any rational person."

Full article here.

[Thanks to MacDailyNews Reader "Stoo" for the heads up.]

MacDailyNews Take: Get a Mac.

Bookmark and Share

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Reader Feedback: = registered.
Unregistered users: Feedback from multiple usernames are subject to deletion. Off-topic and posts from suspected astroturfers will be removed.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:12 pm Comment from: Ampar

" . . . it remains unsuitable for use to any rational person."

Welcome to the monkey's house.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:25 pm Comment from: G4Dualie

Never really understood how bad it is until now. Anti-user? Indeed.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:30 pm Comment from: DavidO

From the original article:

"My girlfriend sits beside me browsing on a Mac."

At least somebody has some brains in that relationship.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:31 pm Comment from: Macaday

Until I read this I thought I was a rabid Windows hater!

Jan 30, 08 - 12:33 pm Comment from: Heh

Microsoft(R)

Our connections. Your conniptions.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:36 pm Comment from: Rich Apple person

There is a more serious issue here: 5 years and billions of dollars and Vista was the result? Microsoft has become corporate America and in doing so has lost the passion that once made it great. Most mac users hate MS but to their credit they did bring the PC to the masses and still have a 90% market share. Vista was a MAJOR disappointment and shows what happens when you try to make too much money for something that has no value to your base. Most companies are sticking with XP and will continue to do so and now MS is delaying the next version of Windows till 2011?? One has to wonder if Apple can maintain their innovation when Mr Jobs retires

Jan 30, 08 - 12:38 pm Comment from: Micro Me

I've never used Vista, but everything I've heard from PC users about it is negative.

Last week, a visitor gave us an unexpurgated account of his Vista experience, ending with his reversion to XP. It made my problems with Leopard on my workplace Mac pale into insignificance.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:39 pm Comment from: Ampar

"If you can't make it good, at least make it look good.”

"Let's face it, the average computer user has the brain of a spider monkey."

"We've got to put a lot of money into changing behavior."

- Bill Gates

Jan 30, 08 - 12:47 pm Comment from: mike_in_helsinki

The way you handle a turd is simple. Flush the smelly, vile business down the commode, hope that the brown, glancing blows to the porcelain sides do not show the skid marks too badly.

Apply chloride vigorously, and repeat.

Jan 30, 08 - 12:51 pm Comment from: eyerhyme

I think MacDaily News needs to iCal this comment on the article. 10% is coming real fast there Andrew... can we get your email too so we can all call you out! Expensive and underpowered? Right... check a comparable Dell to a MacPro with the same specs.

"For Jobs Mob to take any Market Share they need to release a version of Mac OS that doesn't require expensive underpowered Apple supplied hardware, or hacking to make it work on a custom build box. Untill you can buy a value(read cheap) HP/DELL for around £300-400 (with screen) with OS X on it Apple will never ever take more than 10% of the market"
posted by : andrew, 30 January 2008

Jan 30, 08 - 12:54 pm Comment from: 84 Mac Guy

How refreshing to read an article and all the comments that primarily pit the Vista nuts against the Linux crowd. Us Mac fanboys tend to think of everything in terms of Apple, but the Linux fans have the same arguments with the MS fanboys.

Interestingly Linux fans and Apple folks are more than just allies against a common enemy, they are brothers with the same mother--Unix. In contrast, Vista is a bastard child.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:01 pm Comment from: bizlaw

What's amazing is that he "was forced to learn Linux" due to Vista, but his girlfriend uses a Mac. I wonder why he didn't try her Mac, instead of being forced to learn Linux? Maybe because he didn't want to replace hardware?

Jan 30, 08 - 01:04 pm Comment from: ken1w

> MS was forcing me to use Linux against my will

Linux is getting much better as a client OS, but it's NOT nearly as refined as Mac OS X. I tried Ubuntu, Fedora, and SUSE on my Mac through VMware Fusion. They work fine for common tasks like web-browsing, but I definitely felt a relaxing sense of comfort and well-being when I was back in the Mac environment. And while I would use Linux instead of Windows, there is no way I would use Linux instead of Mac OS X. As it stands now, PC makers like Dell are in for a disappointment if they believe Linux is a viable alternative to Windows for most of their customers.

With no other alternative to Windows Vista, other than Windows XP, Apple's competitors are in for a rough three to four years. Apple may actually achieve 20% U.S. market share for Macs during that time, since Mac OS X is the only true long-term alternative to Windows Vista for most customers.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:16 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

"Inviolate promises of user control over patching was shown to be far less important than MS needs to control your box"

NOBODY controls my box.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:23 pm Comment from: Locked, Activated, Loaded with Spyware & DRM

Just the thing for the police state we are living in. The BushWorld poster child computer where you have 'no expectation of privacy'.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:29 pm Comment from: Mr. Sensible

"Apple may actually achieve 20% U.S. market share for Macs during that time, since Mac OS X is the only true long-term alternative to Windows Vista for most customers."

Exactly.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:31 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

Four billion wordwide
population - all living - have a
Computer God Containment Policy
Brain Bank Brain, a real brain, in the
Brain Bank Cities on the far side of the
moon we never see. Primarily based
on your lifelong Frankenstein Radio
Controls, especially your Eyesight TV
sight-and-sound recorded by your brain,
your moon-brain of the Computer God
activates your Frankenstein threshold
Brainwash Radio - lifelong inculcating
conformist propaganda. Even frightening
you and mixing you up and the usual
"Don't worry about it" for your setbacks,
mistakes - even when you receive
deadly injuries!

THIS is the Worldwide Computer God Secret Containment Policy!

Jan 30, 08 - 01:31 pm Comment from: anaknipedro

@ eyerhyme
I did as you suggested. The result was MacPro: $2799 vs Dell Precision Workstation: $4665.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:37 pm Comment from: ericdano

Ooooo, so THAT is why Zune Tang uses it. He is not rational.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:37 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

Gangster Computer God Worldwide
Secret Containment Policy made possible
solely by Worldwide Computer God Frankenstein
Controls. Especially lifelong constant-threshold
Brainwash Radio. Quiet and motionless, I can
slightly hear it. Repeatedly this has saved my life
on the streets!

Jan 30, 08 - 01:51 pm Comment from: Paul Zune's Bone Machine

I have a Vista box at work, and to my surprise I actually like it. Of course, it's running on a fate Core2 Duo, so performance isn't an issue. It really isn't that different from XP, just shinier.

Jan 30, 08 - 01:58 pm Comment from: en

I just do not know why people think that the best machine in the world is a POC (piece of crap) box that is underpowered, under memory, and contains the cheapest parts of hardware one can find in the world, and they want to load Apple OS on it.

To me, its like buying a Gucci interior and putting it on a go-cart and wondering why the ride really sucks while driving in the rain, in heavy traffic.

JMHO

en

Jan 30, 08 - 01:59 pm Comment from: doc

@bizlaw

Charlie Demerjian evaluates lots of different hardware and software, much of which will not work on a mac but will have compatibility with a peecee.

BTW:
Is that deal on I offered you? You said aapl would be over $200us by the end of this week and I offered to sell you some aapl at $195us on 4feb08.

Jan 30, 08 - 02:38 pm Comment from: Twenty Benson

@ChrissyOne
"NOBODY controls my box."

I hope they do sometimes... or you're missing out big-time wink

Jan 30, 08 - 02:43 pm Comment from: Ampar

Twenty Benson: Yeah, I was thinking that she should at least give Energizer a shot at it.

Jan 30, 08 - 02:52 pm Comment from: dmv

just as I was thinking about controlling and C1's box, I'm beaten to the punch.

Jan 30, 08 - 02:59 pm Comment from: Old Mac Man

NOBODY controls my box.

Thumb in one hole and two fingers in the other. The other hand on your throat.

You'll love me for it. I'd swear.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:08 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

@ Ampar

Puny batteries? I think not.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:20 pm Comment from: Mark

I've been using Windows at work since its inception, and the more I use it, the more I think, "The more I use Windows, the more I love my Mac." I have a wife I love, two cats I adore, and a Mac. Sometimes when I return from work, I'm not sure which to kiss first.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:24 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

It's okay to love your pets, as long as you don't... *love* your pets.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:30 pm Comment from: Twenty Benson

@ ChrissyOne
Looks more like assault and battery.

If that's yer box though... it's got a very nice button.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:36 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

Oops! Wrong link...

Jan 30, 08 - 03:39 pm Comment from: British Mac Head

Yep, No Zune Tang on here Either. Point proven!!!

Zune Tang, who are you really?

If you were a real Vista nerd you would be on here defending your crappy OS.

Arf arf!!!

Jan 30, 08 - 03:46 pm Comment from: Mark

@ChrissyOne

Don't worry, it's a platonic adoration. That being said, I was at work about a year ago while my wife was away visiting family. I called her and she asked how things were on the home front. I said something like, "Things are going well. Marco was a little darling last night; he came to bed about midnight and was very affectionate. He finally fell asleep nestled right against me." After I hung up, one of the women I worked with said, "Ummmmm, Marco IS your cat, right??? I assured her he was.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:53 pm Comment from: Ampar

"love your pets"
In truth, great movie line.

Re: Honda generator. Those are used now in dentists' offices to power the equipment. It's a new green solution. Patients in pain tend to be more flatulent and therefore produce methane. And everyone knows that abscess makes the fart go Honda.


Re: And that last one? Daaaaaaaaam.

Jan 30, 08 - 03:55 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

@ Mark

You shoulda ran with it. wink "Uh, no, Marco... he's just a friend. He, uh, just likes to snuggle..." {sweats}

Jan 30, 08 - 04:00 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

"And everyone knows that abscess makes the fart go Honda."

That was a long long way for just a little bit... But truly, my hat is off, my friend.

Jan 30, 08 - 04:12 pm Comment from: Mark

@ChrissyOne

Yeah, I could have said, "He's my friend and he's big, and black, and beautiful, and veeery strong." All of which would have been true.

Jan 30, 08 - 04:32 pm Comment from: Veronica

I love that picture of Ballmy and Gates, it makes you just wanna slap there heads

Jan 30, 08 - 05:36 pm Comment from: ChrissyTwo

I see MDN is posting as ChrissyONe again... slow news day?

Jan 30, 08 - 05:50 pm Comment from: ChrissyOne

@ NumberTwo

I laughed so hard I went number one!

Jan 30, 08 - 08:59 pm Comment from: LiM

He's absolutely correct that a Microsoft product is an insult. But the number one reason why some Windows users will resist switching to Mac no matter what pain Windows inflicts on them is... games [see following pages].

For non-gamers or those satisfied by an occasional title like Call of Duty 2, there is no excuse [okay, there is at least three things you can do in Windows that have no equivalent Mac shareware apps...[keep hoping]].

Jan 30, 08 - 11:22 pm Comment from: Trevor

Has it been a year already. I still havn't seen Vista up close so I can't realy comment. If Windows is 95% of the market or whatever then you'd think someone I know has it installed, but no.

Jan 31, 08 - 01:55 am Comment from: awesome Anthony.

boring .. boring....
Please american girls come and get me.

and some fat Rich can give a job please.

I know ms is shit.
so that qualifies me for a job better than a MS employee.
OK

Feb 01, 08 - 01:43 pm Comment from: boulderfrog

When the chrome plating wears off a turd, aren't you left with shit?

Feb 04, 08 - 02:23 am Comment from: dude

Dang, where's Zune Tang? I clicked and read this article to get his twisted take!!!

Reader feedback page 1 of 1 pages:

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Add Your Feedback:

Register or Login

Name:

Email: (optional)

Emoticons | Allowed HTML Tags

Remember my info   Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the "MDN Magic Word" you see in the image below: