MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

1st. I have no life. Eat it Mac dude...

don't be so hard on yourself, pino, just get an iLife. Is Mossberg on someone's payroll? i.e. Apple's? anyway, love seeing a main stream newspaper touting the Mac machine.

Overheard in the checkout line at the supermarket:

Woman Shopper: "Gee, I can't believe they're out of humble pies already! They just went on sale this morning."

10-year old kid: "Yah. I think it has something to do with this fat scrotum sack of a jackass named 'MacDude'."

Woman Shopper: "What do you mean?"

10-year old kid: "Ohh, well, this rod-jockey apparently opened his fat pie hole one too many times on some Mac forum on the internet. Now the big load has to eat so much pie that there's none left for the rest of us normal-size folk. What a knob-gobbler, huh?"

Woman Shopper: "Young man, do you really think you should be talking like that?"

10-year old kid: "Why the f*ck not? I just think he's a motherf*cking asswipe. So do all my friends. And all my parent's friends. I mean, this guy's so pathetic that he actually knocks the Mac every chance he gets. Can you believe it?"

Woman Shopper: "Really? Hmmm . . . what a f*cking shitstain ass monkey."

Walter S. Mossberg: Steve Jobs’ newly adopted son.

How does it stream movies from other computers?
Frontrow doesn't play very nice with xvid/divx here :/

Great article -- lots of facts. Apple has understated the Mac Mini's importance. They are really running market tests by selling this low end computer and having creative people use it as a media center device. They will obviously be using the feedback generated to adjust/tune their architecture and software. For example; the problem Mossberg ran into with an all wireless approach needs to be addressed. The missing software pieces need to be added. Don't you think a media center device also needs an iPod/vPod dock -- right at the media center?

The switch over to HTDV is supposed to be completed by 2009 -- IIRC. The concomitant market for media center devices is huge. Apple needs to finalize its candidate architecture, hardware and software and put it on the market. The time is coming to get those chairs airborne in Microsoft's boardroom.

I could see using the mini in a render farm situation. There is quite a lot of horse power inside one of those little boxes. I could pack a lot of those into my studio and set them up with remote desktop. Something for the future perhaps.... When Pro Apps are UB.

The graphics processor is shit but perfectly fine for web browsing and movie watching etc.

Pino, I laughed so hard I about blew my cork out. Unbelievable.

Nice that besides a place for discussing our favorite computer MDN can be a light hearted and funny place too.

Mossberg just says it the way it is. If he was Apple's payroll, he would not have mentioned that there were problems with wireless streaming of videos.

I tried this at the Apple Store, streaming a couple of 320x240 iPod videos and one HD trailer for 16 Blocks. The two minis (the playback mini was a Core Duo, the one with videos stored was a Core Solo) were on the same counter at the Store, and I think it was going wirelessly but I didn't check. The HD trailer worked smoothly; no skipping that I could see. One of the iPod videos was real jumpy but I think it must've been the networking. And Front Row did stall a couple of times - leaving me with a black screen with no indication it was doing anything and making me exit back to the Finder.

Anyone else try it out yet?

Biggest complaint I have about the sharing of music and videos is the fact that Apple isn't doing this from a client-server view. In order to share your music and videos, you must have iTunes running on each computer that you want to share from. That means you must be logged in to each computer. Which leads to another big problem. We have multiple libraries for iPhoto on our PowerMac at home. You can only share the photos of the library thats currently open.

Its time Apple do something from a client server perspective instead of always thinking about the desktop only. Give us the ability to link to an iPhoto library or iTunes library over a local network from within the iLife apps. Sure, we can always create a share, but give us the ability to point to the address within your apps.

You can do something similar with a Windows PC that uses Microsoft's Media Center software. In fact, Media Center does more than Front Row, because it's also capable of receiving and recording TV programs. Microsoft has been ahead of Apple in this area, and Media Center is very well designed.

I bought a fully loaded mini for my wife, and I have been, very, very impressed.

I too think Apple is sandbagging the true purpose of the mini...and time will tell what Apple has in store for us...

The switch over to HTDV is supposed to be completed by 2009

You mean the switch to all digital TV... All the channels are not going to be HD. They mean 480i digital. I've run into a lot of people who think HD because of how unclear the media is when they talk about the transition.

Emil. I have a month old minimac that I used to stream episodes of Battle Star Galactica thru a shared itunes library on my 12" pwrbook and display on my 32" LCD HDTV aside from mild scaling degradation there were no issues. I imagine that the newer minimacs will work out just fine.

That's sounding pino noir. Nice work.

Linux guy, I fon't think that Apple has understated the importance of the minimac as you say. Although I agree with the majority of you reasoning, I'd submit that by your own conclusions Apple has deliberately not stated anything due to the flux of the broadcast situation with HDTV, lack of a firm industry commitment to bluray, develop and comitment to the next generation high speed wireless. Any declaration of positioning for the minimac at this time would be premature. In 2 years the minimac could be a large local server that you buy for $450 with a new 6 or 7G ipod with touch tablet capability being the computer/remote/mp3player/cellphone/ digital camera/GPS thingy running googlge earth via sattelite so you never get lost or are without evtertainment or productivity tools. But I digress...there's just too much flux righ now to cast anything in stone.

I don't think WM is Apple's pocket at all, but he obviously has deeper links into that org than the average tech writer. It is interesting that when he makes a complaint about a feature or certain performance, he is able to to write that Apple is doing this or that to address his concern. I rarely see this indication of a direct pipeline into key Apple people from other writers. Apple obviously makes an effort to keep him well informed.

bradychase has the right idea: The curent Mini we see IS hobbled due to the flux we're seeing regarding what the content owners are finally going to back on the HD front. however, there is another issue - the fact that there are millions and millions of 'unsecurable' PPC Macs out there, that have to be somewhat connected to what Apple's doing on the home entertainment front. I think that's why everything is still tied through iTunes - it's sort of the poor man's DRM. Once Apple gets the green light on a few technical issues from their new Overlords at Intel, we'll start to see a major shift.

Basically, I predict the Macintel Mini will become more 'server-like' as a media hub. It will be completely locked down so that anything on it will be unalterable - or even expireable, so that you have to keep buying 'rights' to play your music or watch your vids - and this will be when Apple introduces a DVR like capability. Not before.

There will still be a degree of interoperability between PPC Macs, as well as Windows machines with iTunes (btw - I ALSO predict an iPhoto variant for Windows is coming, as this is just too big a whole in the present feature set - even Mossberg mentions it). However, this will only last for as long as Apple thinks there is money to be made from it - i.e. that there are enough PPC Macs out there to bother supporting. Plus the features available to the PPC world will steadily shrink, resembling the present situation with having just iTunes as the thread connecting Apple's multimedia efforts to the Windows world now. As soon as Apple perceives the fulcrum tipping toward Macintel (or even as way of accerating that process), they will dump PPC support. Those venerable old machines are just too dangerously non-TPM'd.

Windows machines will probably always be supported in some way, just b/c there's so damn many people who will still be using them. But once Vista gets here, Apple will dutifuly stop supplying upgrades to the XP & Earlier versions - again, due to their being less secure vis a vis Vista.

This is Apple's strategy. As I said almost from the beginning of this whole Macintel announcement - PPC offers a much better CPU architecture going forward than anything on the x86 side. And AMD will continue doing Intel up the wazzoo in x86 performance, until eventually they will own the lion's share of the traditional computing market. All of this has been obvious and forseeable for quite some time. so rest assured that Apple chose to go to Intel because of what DRM tech and corporate legitimacy Intel could provide them, in getting the content providers to loosen their grip on their video libraries. Jobs himeslf, being a major media mogal himself now, was all-to-easy a mark on this. His sympathies are leaning more towards that industry - and away from making Insanely Great computers - with every passing day. To the extent that he still cares about making enough product to beat M$, he's hoping that video will provide the leverage to break Gate's near insurmountable markeshare lead (insurmountable in Jobs's likely lifetime, at least) with traditional computers. If Apple's multimedia offerings get popular enough (watch the iPod & Macintel Mini here), the assumption is that Windows PCs will either become exinct, or inexorably 'enslaved' to whatever device Apple makes for the living room (and THAT will sell even faster than PCs).

Hey, call me crazy. But that's how I see it.


PS - stop dissing Macdude. He's certainly been more accurate on this stuff than you other AAPL Lemmings.