Shattered Windows: HP tries putting lipstick on Windows Vista pig; working on own Linux-based OS

“The ecosystem that Microsoft has built up around its Windows operating system is showing signs of strain. In one of several recent moves by partners that sell or support the company’s software, Hewlett-Packard, the world’s No. 1 PC maker, has quietly assembled a group of engineers to develop software that will let customers bypass certain features of Vista, the latest version of Windows. Employees on a separate skunk works team are even angling to replace Windows with an HP-assembled operating system, say three sources close to the company,” Aaron Ricadela reports for BusinessWeek.

“‘Our customers are looking for insanely simple technology where they don’t have to fight with the technology to get the task done,’ says Phil McKinney, chief technology officer in HP’s PC division,” Ricadela reports. “McKinney says any discussions about building an operating system to rival Windows are happening below senior-management levels. He doesn’t deny some employees may have had such conversations, but he says HP isn’t devoting substantial resources to such projects. ‘Is HP funding a huge R&D team to go off and create an operating system? [That] makes no sense,’ he says. ‘For us it’s about innovating on top of Vista.'”

“Still, the sources say employees in HP’s PC division are exploring the possibility of building a mass-market operating system. HP’s software would be based on Linux, the open-source operating system that is already widely available, but it would be simpler and easier for mainstream users, the sources say. The goal may be to make HP less dependent on Windows and to strengthen HP’s hand against Apple, which has gained market share in recent years by offering easy-to-use computers with its own operating system,” Ricadela reports.

“One person who has advised HP executives on strategy says they are concerned that Apple could develop a notebook computer that would sell for less than $1,000. That’s a fast-growing market HP depends on for sales where Apple has yet to compete. “Apple is a huge motivating factor,” says the source,” Ricadela reports.

Full article here.

Rigid churros, indeed.

69 Comments

  1. “The goal may be to make HP less dependent on Windows . . .”

    That’s just silly. The next groundbreaking and more funner version of Windows is only 3 to 5 to 10 to 15 years away. And then another and then . . .

  2. I could do well, but if people move away from Windows, they tend to go to the Mac, but that may be because the Mac is easier to use than Linux. If HP make a Linux based OS for their hardware, things could get interesting.

    I say go for it HP, as I can’t see Windows getting better anytime soon. It is good a business strategy preparing the company for a world with out Windows.

  3. New MacBooks starting at 929.99- sounds good and is below the 1000.00 mark. Yea, can dream.

    Just improve in small amounts and look what happens. The market starts to strain as a market moves. Then large almost unchangable starts to change. Good sign, more innovation and perhaps even cheaper prices.

    Microsoft, get ready to photocopy- Apple makes things simple, elegant, and steadly….. Whoooooooooa, copy is broken now?!

  4. Windows COULD get better, but it won’t. What they need to do to Windows is a ground-up complete rewrite that breaks backward compatibility. They’re convinced that no one will buy Windows if it won’t run a 12 year old character-based version of Zork III, and that’s not true.

    But it really doesn’t matter, does it?

  5. “Hewlett-Packard, the world’s No. 1 PC maker, has quietly assembled a group of engineers to develop software that will let customers bypass certain features of Vista…”

    Too bad ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”raspberry” style=”border:0;” />

    Yeah, that’s the ticket.

  6. Seems to me the perfect storm is brewing for Microsoft to start to die. iPhones and Macs are working their way into the enterprise. I work for a NASDAQ traded company with a global reach, 2000+ employees and iPhones are popping up everywhere. And, shocker, Macs are starting too as well. Google releases Chrome. Windows box assemblers (HP, Dell, etc.) are getting tired of waiting on Microsoft and are starting to put in place little ways to work around/independent of Windows. How long before they do what HP is talking about in this article? Vista uptake continues to lag, MS is putting out ads with old white guys that make no sense. Applications are moving to the cloud, whether it be through Google or something else. If functionality can all be there, without the headaches, what is my compelling reason for ever buying Windows? The fat lady is polishing the horns on her Viking helmet…

  7. “… concerned that Apple could develop a notebook computer that would sell for less than $1,000.” Luckily for HP, Apple’s notebooks start at $1,099; so I guess they’re safe for now. 😎

    Seriously, the notion of a non-Windows, especially one based on Linux, is laughable. Would they be relying on Wine to run those Windows apps? More likely, they’d try to release a version stripped to its core foundation. But given that the boundary between OS and bundled apps has never been clean, separation would be painfully difficult. Recalling the Justice vs. Microsoft trial, they spent a lot of time on the viability of pulling Internet Explorer out of Windows. I doubt it’s much easier today.

  8. It strikes me that rather than building yet another desktop OS, which would only put HP a decade or so behind Windows and the Mac OS, it would be more effective to leap frog the desktop OS world. The desktop world is diminishing. The cloud is where it’s at, or going to be within the next few years.

    HP should partner with companies like Google and concentrate on building personal Google machines, or PGMs.

    This would be a thin client primarily targeted at running Google Apps over the Internet and selling for less than $300.

  9. Hmmm… I seriously think a 3rd platform is emerging in the Cloud. Imagine all of your basic administrative functions living in the cloud. Calendar, Contacts, E-mail, Finances, Project Management, all that sort of stuff already lives there. All you need is a little, {cough}, Chrome polisher and you’re there. You really don’t need some $2000 dual core fire breathing machine to manage your contacts and print the occasional list.

    These sorts of functions can live on your Android Phone, your HP Google Machine, etc.

    Apple and Microsoft are doomed. Oh well, at least they can sell iPods and Zunes.

  10. This is not news. HP has been doing lots of Linux development for the last ten years. And as noted, what are all these ostensibly disgruntled users going to run on their Linux boxes? Linux has been around a long time. If people wanted it, they’d have it by now.

    Non-strategy if there ever was one.

  11. @mr.reee

    as unix is to osx. linux to… hp-os?

    they would only have to build a shell for linux, and include drives for the components HP sells in each machine. hp will have to push for third party printer drivers, but they are big on printers too, so at least they can roll out their own printers to be ready for their os.

    i can really see this working. of course with a lot of hard work, but still possible.

  12. @curious

    that’s fine, but I believe Apple can compete in that space. Google isn’t going to supplant Apple or Microsoft in your lifetime.

    I can’t speak to Android because I don’t own one but I will say that the iPod/iPhone and the App Store already has a seven-year head start.

  13. Fragmenting up the OS Market into say 5 to 20 different OS choices based on hardware Vendor would be good for everyone in the end. Except the software Vendors that are so Windows Centric it would be impossible for them to move to cross-platform support.

    IBM should resurrect OS2 Warp for Lennovo.
    Or create a desktop version of AIX for Sony
    Sun should release a desktop version of Solaris.
    HP should do a desktop version HPUX for it’s PCs
    Who ever owns the BeOS code should get a wiggle on and release an OEM it to a Hardware maker. Dell would most likely stay with Windows.

  14. Considering office suites and many applications are moving toward web apps written in Java or Javascript, HP or other PC manufactures could come out with a Linux or BSD based operating system, which is very good at running Firefox or Google Chrome, but nothing else. Back to old computer business model, where Operating Systems were background software no one really cared about.

  15. exactly. and if there is enough of a market within that OS platform. independent software creators can sell their apps etc.

    i see this is a great thing in the future.

    ps. bring back the amiga

  16. I’m surprised nobody has tried this before. Way to go is copy Apple’s strategy but with a well thought out OS based on Linux and a bundled suite of apps that does everything most people want to do.

    Apply some design to the box, sell it at the right price and it should fly.

    MS days of bullying are numbered.

  17. Sub $1000 Apple Notebook? It’s called the iPhone/iPod touch. Good luck w/ that innovation HP. Seriously. If you can figure out how to innovate on top of Vista, that’s worth some kind of recognition. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”wink” style=”border:0;” />

  18. HP is no stranger to Unix. HP-UX, their proprietary Unix OS, has been in commercial release since 1983. The current version, 11i v3, scales to the following specs:

    * 128 processors
    * 2 TB main memory
    * 32 TB maximum file system
    * 16 TB maximum file size
    * 100 million ZB storage

  19. “For us [HP] it’s about innovating on top of Vista.”

    Talk about building a house on quicksand!!! It is not unfair to say that Windows Vista—especially when you consider the big build-up preceding its long-overdue release—has been the most spectacular disaster in the history of computer software. That’s not an easy thing to accomplish. Microsoft should be proud!

  20. Oh, yeah, here’s the link to HP-UX:

    http://h20338.www2.hp.com/hpux11i/cache/324545-0-0-0-121.html?jumpid=go/hpux

    Seriously, it sounds like many of you only know of HP as a consumer printer and PC company. That’s just the tip of the iceberg. Their presence in large enterprise is… well, large.

    If HP decide to get serious about building an alternative operating system to Windows, I would say they’re one of the few companies that have the engineering background to pull it off.

  21. HP could come out with a dual boot machine, one that does Vista for people that have MS stuff, and then, reboot in to HP-OS and have a basic, simple, easy to use and reliable box for web surfing, writing letters, photography, video….. hmmmm sort of like iLife but without Windows.

    They could offer the dual boot system with and without Windows installed. For people like my mom who just want to do the simple stuff, who needs Windows? The Window-less version could be a little cheaper and have an option to add windows later.

    Frankly, I’ve wondered for years why HP did not do this.

  22. If any of these box makers – Dell, HP – have to guts to devote a substantial resource in R&D;to create an easy Linux with customer fit into their own $500 notebooks without fear of MS retribution, it could own the future PC market, not to mention actually “innovate” BECAUSE they don’t have to fit into Windows and actually have stuff comparable to Apple. Fortunately none of these guys are smart enough or daring enough.

  23. Did you use “lipstick” and “pig” in a sentance? That can only mean you are insulting Sarah Palin! How dare you! I am offended.

    Nice try. Obama’s intentions were very clear, however he tries to spin it.

    And if it WAS accidental, it shows a glaring lack of statesmanship skills. What happens when he insults, say, Russia or North Korea in a similar manner?

    As for HP? It’s gotta suck to rely so heavily on MS.

  24. @Macs King — good idea, but go one step farther. For the people who want it, why not virtualize a Windows shell on top of Linux? HP already has full virtualization under HP-UX:

    http://h71028.www7.hp.com/enterprise/cache/258348-0-0-0-121.html

    I’m not an HP-UX geek, although I have done some work under it. It’s a mainframe Unix, it’s not a desktop OS. All I’m saying is, they’ve already got the foundation in-house, just like Apple built OS X on top of Next’s BSD/Mach. They aren’t starting from scratch.

    All HP would have to do — if they wanted to — would be to scale their enterprise HP-UX down to desktop proportions and build a nice GUI front end. Add Windows emulation, and Presto… they’ve got their own desktop OS.

    The question is, do they want to compete in this arena.

  25. > For us it’s about innovating on top of Vista.

    A hopeless task.

    So is developing an in-house OS.

    So is making Linux appealing to the masses.

    And Apple WILL have a sub-$1000 laptop for this holiday season. They already do, if you count the 2.1 GHz Core 2 Duo MacBook refurbs at the Apple Store selling for $899.

  26. Asus is already building a lightweight Linux into their motherboards that loads in a couple of seconds. I suppose if cloud computing really takes off all the other hardware manufactures will follow suit and Microsoft (and maybe even Apple) will be in trouble.

  27. “Good. Everybody benefits when there is competition based on innovation.”

    Totally agree with that. Before I went Mac, I had great experiences with HP, both from a hardware and service perspective. I would love to see them apply some resources to this. If it puts added pressure on MS and helsp them stay further ahead of Dell, that’s all good.

  28. I know loads of people who are buying Wyse terminals for the home. Now you can get them with Firefox, Java, Flash, etc. built in, they can’t see the point of keeping a PC around.

    Things are most definitely changing. HP could very well succeed here.

  29. Oh bite me with the Palin bits already, good grief, what a bunch of babies! Absolutely chomping at the bit here to send that flea bag and her fashion glasses back to Alaska for good. Fifteen minutes of her has been way to much. Hang on world, it’s almost over now. Let’s see… HP, pigs, lipstick, linux…Oh I give up!

    Go Apple!

  30. After reading about the rubbish MS are pulling in their desperate $300 million marketing blitz to try to sell Vista I got the hint that MS have begun a downward spiral of desperation. ‘Guru’ marketing dweebs who can’t even answer your Vista user questions. HA!

    An now we get the hint that HP want out of the Windows hegemony.

    I don’t see MS dying. Sorry all you DOOM mongers. But I do see them fading into irrelevance if this decay mode keeps up. I expect to see steam blasting out of Ballmer’s red ears by the middle of next year. Maybe then we can get back on track with the actual computer revolution MS has stalled.

  31. I want to buy[url=”http://www.uggaustralianew.com/ “]boots

    shoes[/url],my friends told me about[url=”http://www.uggaustralianew.com/ “]ugg

    boots[/url],they said[url=”http://www.uggaustralianew.com/

    “]uggs[/url]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.