The Motley Fool: Intel gives Apple a free pass while everyone else is supposed to use Viiv

“At a recent trade show in Japan, a senior Intel executive praised newfound partner Apple or its consumer-friendly, proprietary entertainment platform,” Anders Bylund writes for The Motley Fool. “Then he turned right around and prayed for Japanese electronics manufacturers to support the open standards of Intel’s Viiv entertainment platform — which is notably incompatible with iPods and iTunes. Want another cake while you’re eating this one, Intel?”

“‘Let Apple be Apple,’ said Eric Kim, senior VP of Intel’s home entertainment group,” Bylund writes. “The fact that Steve Jobs and his merry men have a virtual stranglehold on the digital music market can inspire its partners to forgive many a flaw, like a tightly locked-down media format that won’t work with anybody else’s hardware until Apple decides to loosen up a bit and start selling third-party licenses.”

MacDailyNews Note: You mean like Motorola? Oops, sorry to break Bylund’s flow.

Bylund continues, “Even Intel, provider of the chips powering today’s Macs, doesn’t have the right to sell gadgets or software that can play your iTunes downloads, and the chipmaker seems OK with that.”

“I’m a big fan of open standards myself, and would be happy to see Apple’s closed platform opened up so I could buy songs through iTunes and play them on my Creative Zen media player. Intel is in a position to push Apple into licensing its FairPlay digital rights management scheme to Viiv devices. Giving Apple a free pass while everyone else is supposed to get in line makes Intel look like a wishy-washy turncoat that doesn’t really believe in its own product,” Bylund writes. “‘At the end of the day, consumers want choice,’ Kim said. But no matter what they choose, Intel wants to be a part of the solution.”

Full article here.
You want to play iTunes content on a media player, Mr. Bylund? Then get an iPod.

Apple should not license FairPlay to others unless and/or until it makes business sense, not because someone wants to buy an also-ran device and buy from Apple’s iTunes Store. Also-ran device buyers like Mr. Bylund should use the also-ran online media outfits to which they’ve consigned themselves with their purchasing mistake, er… decision.

Intel is not “giving Apple a pass.” Intel doesn’t tell Apple what to do. Never forget: Universal Binary means it runs on Intel and PowerPC (and there’s always AMD for those that like to compute a bit more leisurely). Intel needs to keep working hard to keep Apple’s business and thanking them profusely for it.

Related articles:
Motto inside Intel: ‘Let Apple be Apple’ – October 03, 2006
Apple’s vs. Microsoft’s music DRM: whose solution supports more users? – August 17, 2005
The de facto standard for legal digital online music files: Apple’s protected MPEG-4 Audio (.m4p) – December 15, 2004

47 Comments

  1. what are these people griping about? why cry about not having the ability to play iTunes purchases on a non-ipod device? if they have an also-ran device, there are a number of services out there they can use to purchase their songs. if they don’t want to buy an ipod, then, don’t buy music from iTunes!

  2. drives me nuts…how come everyone who ever said “Apple needs to license FairPlay” uses “consumers want choices” as their arguement???? Isn’t the fact that consumers want choices reflected in the fact that people either chose to buy an iPod and use iTunes or not????

  3. I would accept and possibly even enjoy Windows if it had the best and most intuitive products. That is the difference…the iPod a combination of the best and the most intuitive hardware in the iPod and software in iTunes 7.
    The next generation is smarter…it is more about quality these days. The sheep are simply moving to greener pastures, and it is just beginning.

  4. Another good, balanced rejoinder, MDN. Your “get an iPod” line is so blindly pro-Apple that it’s just silly. What if the answer to “I want to run [insert a Windows-only application]” is “get a PC”. You’d be all over yourselves excoriating them for being closed-minded, bla bla bla.

    I still want to see FairPlay become the defacto DRM standard for ALL digital music devices. That way, Apple makes money if they sell their own product *or* somebody else’s product, via royalties. And Apple’s market domination would be just as strong as it is now, because their solution, absent any DRM discussion, is far better than the rest of the market. And if FairPlay is ubiquitous, consumers don’t have to think about what device will play what song, which is a big win.

  5. It definitely sounds like the author is biased against Apple.

    He wants Intel to make Apple use their standard like everyone else????
    – I guess he wants Apple to be mediocre like the rest of the industry.

    And how is Intel in the position to push Apple to license Fairplay?

    And we’re suppose to take this fools advice with our money?

  6. It’s not about closed versus open,

    it’s about a solution vs chaos.

    Which is exactly why Microsoft has seen the light and initiated Zune. This is a validation of Apple’s approach to meeting the needs of consumers.

  7. I always get a kick out of the pundits that trumpet “the customer wants choice” line. I call bullshit. The “customer” has chosen Windows something like 90% of the time and rarely gripes that they don’t have a myriad of other choices. I have never met anyone that feels strongly that they want to be able to buy from a selection of different music stores. “Customers” perceive choice as, “Can I choose to download the music I want?” If they answer is yes, they are not hung up of the store that it comes from. Customers like the iPod and they buy from the store that works with it. Can one choose Willie Nelson while another chosses Metallica while another chooses Nelly while another chooses Frank Sinatra? Yes. That is the choice that matters.

  8. I have to admit…I’m a complete Apple guy and have iPods, MacBook Pro, 30″ display and just love it all….

    But…

    I absolutely love my Sony Ericsson W810i phone…best I’ve ever used and I think the UI just blows the door off any Motorola one (as I’ve had 2 RAZRs and a SLVR)….

    It’s really too bad that I have to put so much effort into putting my purchased iTunes songs onto it. It’s not like Apple actually makes an iPod cell phone. If they did I’d probably get that if it were as good as the w810, but in the mean time it really frustrates me that they wont’ work out better deals with more than the crap SLVR and the stupid song limit.

    Surely even the ultimate Apple fans on this site can agree with this, no?

  9. Eric is right.

    This guy, Bylund, can buy music (and even get subscriptions! WOW!) from a plethora of online services. Napster, Rhapsody, Wal-Mart, Amazon, Urge (is that still around?), and others I’ve unfortunately forgotten.

    Instead, he longs to buy music from iTunes Store.

    Bylund, just wait. Best Buy will likely offer the online music store you have been longing for.

    Not!

  10. I think from a business sense, now is the time. If Apple licenses FairPlay, all the WMA music sites will fade to nothing. Since FairPlay music is tied to Quicktime then Quicktime becomes the standard. Once that happens, WMV becomes irrelavent. Apple makes money on FairPlay/Quicktime for the rest of forever. Microsoft fades to oblivion. iTMS (sorry iTS) is well established now. Capture the battle field now, not a year from now when competition forces the issue.

  11. hairbo have you tried to use a “PlaysforSure” service? I’ve tried with Rhapsody, Napster and Urge.

    Not a pretty site. Each time the install warned me that I needed an update and that I would need new licenses for all the windows media on the other stores.

    It is a buggy confusing mess, and even Napster’s CEO has hinted at this.

    We don’t need iTunes reputation tainted by buggy un-coordinated implementations of Fairplay in other players.

    Quality control is important, and we’ve never really had that in the PC market. Please don’t bring that mess to iPod+iTunes.

    A better target for energy is to convince labels to release tracks in MP3 format, without DRM.

    But leave the the iPod+iTunes integration alone.

  12. Hey Hairbo:

    Although I understand what you would want in a prerfect world that all hardware works with all software.

    I think you need to be hard on MS as well.
    It seems any software they are now creating will work only on MS operating systems (except MS Office – but who knows how long that will last).

  13. AGGGGGG.
    Enough already!!! I can’t take it anymore.

    He says with a straight text line, “I’m a big fan of open standards myself, and would be happy to see Apple’s closed platform opened up so I could buy songs through iTunes and play them on my Creative Zen media player.”

    Almost every line is full of meaningless crap. 🙁

    “I like open standards”, that is why I like micro crap. !!! (Zune is even more closed than the others) ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    open “Apple’s closed platform”, er its the only one that allows mp3 legally. ???? How open can you get???

    “buy songs from iTunes and play on my Creative Zen” Cheeze, lazy bum. Buy, rip, burn!!! But I guess he is just to lazy to do anything for himself.

    Hey, I got to stop, cause I could go on and on. ” width=”19″ height=”19″ alt=”grin” style=”border:0;” />

    N.

  14. gforce,
    The argument is not “consumers want choices.” Rather, the argument is “consumer choice is better for consumers.” There’s a difference. And no, consumer choice is not always accurately reflected by marketshare. That should be obvious by now.

    Thinking that the issue of opening up FairPlay is limited to the desire to use also-ran mp3 players is quite naive. The scope is far greater than that. Sure, it’s not too bad right now while there are only a limited number of devices that take advantage of the digital entertainment world and while we still have the ability to burn music CDs, but that could change very easily and end up like iTMS tv shows and movies.

    Seriously, why are you guys afraid of Apple opening up? Do you guys actually think that people will stop buying iPods? You’re acting as if people only buy iPods because it’s tied to the iTMS. I would like to think that you know better than that.

  15. idoit…you want choice? Then choose to buy iPod + itunes for a seamless musical/vieo experience. Also choose to buy other mp3 players for the zillion other download services. You have many many options but no, you have to be able to have it ALL. You sound like that brat in the movie Babe….wahhhhhh…its not the right colorrrr!

    Why do so many of these twits whine about choice when there are tons of coices out there. iPod is not the only MP3 player out there. Choose something else…you have the options. But alas, you just choose to whine.

    Ok,,,I’ve griped enough.

  16. @ Robert re: Sony phone

    Apple makes a very portable player for your tunes so you don’t need to waste your cell phone’s battery to play music. Can’t you see the solution in that? It the meantime, it’s a minor inconvenience to get the music onto your phone, and you’re backing it up in the process.

  17. Ha! Coolfactor, how nice of Apple to be so kind as to protect me from using my cell phone’s battery. I suppose the reason why Apple prevents you from burning a movie to a DVD is to prevent you from wasting overworking your television too.

  18. You can play iTunes on any mobile phone. My 16 year old daughter exports her iTunes songs into 3GPP via QuickTime player then copies them over via bluetooth. Since she only wants a few songs she batch exports them quickly. If she can do it (she’s a textiles major, not IT) then any motley fool can.

    Open standards already exist, they just require a little work.

    I agree 100% with macaholic too.

  19. Intel knows whatever Apple comes up with it will beat the pants off Viiv.

    And…ViiV?

    Who the hell is doing Intel’s branding anyway? That’s about the dumbest name ever. Only Microsoft comes up with more ridiculous sounding product names.

  20. @ coolfactor:

    Yes, I do like the form factor of the iPods which is why I have some, but I would like to be able to use songs I’ve purchased on my own phone which I also purchased.

    All I’m saying is that it’d be nice if Apple worked with more than just Motorola to allow us to use our legally purchased items on our devices. I’m not asking for totally open standards, but working with Motorola, Sony and maybe one or 2 other manufacturers would cover a large portion of us who should be able to do what we’d like with our songs.

    Like I also said…..the other option would be for Apple to make their own cell phone and I’d probably jump all over that….but last time I checked that doesn’t exist and all the rumors are just that.

  21. What a bunch of losers. Apple is on top because they figured it out. End of story. The closed system works. The content providers want to safeguard their product and the customers want to own their purchases. Apple provided a means that satisfied both. In the meantime, Apple is making a killing as they should.

    You can’t fit a V-8 from a Ford Mustang into V-8 engine bay of Pontiac Grand Prix. And don’t go bitching to the car companies about it… You buy one an shut the f*ck up. If you want in, BUY AN iPOD stupid. It’s that simple! Stop bitching about incompatibility with other players and the iTUNES Store.

  22. I’m so sick of the weak “choice” argument. A consumer can choose a complete hardware/software platform which happens to be not only easy to use, reliable and happens to dominate the market (Apple and its iPod & iTunes software and store), or another software platform that happens to be buggy, unreliable and doesn’t necessarily plays for sure with the hardware device chosen (Toshiba, et al and Microsoft PlaysForSure). The consumer is an idiot if he wants to choose whatever device he wants and whatever store to buy the songs. But in the end, the fool is struck with a Microsoft platform. I, for one, just wants a solution that works. That’s why Apple’s for me.

  23. @geo: I agree. I think they will do something to open things up one day, as there is much more money for them to be made, as they’ll never be able to physically make every product that people like (PDA’s, Cell Phones, Music Players, etc).

  24. until Apple decides to loosen up a bit and start selling third-party licenses.

    —

    will these morons ever get it…

    open up… open up.. open up… sounds like the Iraq talking points all over again

  25. No one has to use ViiV or PlaysForSure or any so-called “open” standard. The companies that use them choose to use them. Apple chooses to do things on its own. Apple does not need a “free pass” from Intel.

  26. I’m so fed up with journalists who call for Apple to license their DRM. The real solution to this digital mediamess is remove DRM altogether. Then any device that supported the MP4 format could play music/video from iTunes.

    Since DRM is inherently closed & proprietary, I see absolutely no difference between less closed (PlaysForSure) and more closed (FairPlay). They’re both closed; end of story. What we need is open!

    Down with DRM!

    Jared

  27. hairbo: “Another good, balanced rejoinder, MDN. Your “get an iPod” line is so blindly pro-Apple that it’s just silly.
    …I still want to see FairPlay become the defacto DRM standard for ALL digital music devices. That way, Apple makes money if they sell their own product *or* somebody else’s product”

    And how is that NOT blindly pro-Apple?

  28. Has anyone considered that Apple may be using the viiv hardware for the iTV? Just like Intel put together the hardware for the iMac etc, Apple are using Intel to design the boards. It’s cheaper to get Intel to do this. Apple work on the front end which is what they do best.

  29. “I’m a big fan of open standards myself, and would be happy to see Apple’s closed platform opened up so I could buy songs through iTunes and play them on my Creative Zen media player. “

    I really don’t understand the logic here. If you have a Creative Zen media player, why would you want to buy a song from the iTunes store, when:

    1: It’s not compatible with your player, and:

    2: THE EXACT SAME SONG IS AVAILABLE ON COUNTLESS OTHER MUSIC STORES THAT ARE COMPATIBLE WITH THE ZEN.

    Why would you demand of Apple to open up the iTS? Are the songs different in any way? No, they’re not, so what’s his problem?

    Aah, his problem is DRM, so then why pick on Apple?

    DRM is present in every digital music store because the record labels want it this way – get over it, DRM exists and will exist whether you like it or not.

    Your only solace is that you must choose the DRM with the weakest DRM – Apple.

    This article is a coded attack against Apple’s dominance. He’s discouraging his readers from buying Apple, so that every geeks favourite company – Microsoft – can overrule us all with the Zune.

  30. He bloody well can listen to it on his crappy Zen player. He has to burn it to a CD first and then import it. What’s so difficult?

    This whole issue is big load of horse manure.

    And as for arguing there should be NO DRM at all, which planet are they living on? Why aren’t they complaining that shops charge them for a CD? Why should I pay to see a movie at the cinema? Books, no DRM we all want them – for free. “THEY SHOULD ALL BE FREE! NO CHARGES, NO DRM” they should say.

    Idiots. Definitely

    Communists?

  31. <sigh>
    Macaday,
    Who here is arguing that there should be no DRM because they feel that music should be free? No one is arguing that, which makes your rant completely meaningless. It’s easy to argue against a strawman that doesn’t exist, but in the end it just makes you look foolish.

  32. Intel is not giving Apple a pass. VIIV is a system for Windows, not Linux, Unix, Apple or anything else that might be out there. The real question here is why don’t these comentators also push Microsoft to lisence Plays4Sure or Intel to lisence VIIV to the Mac, Linux, etc. if they are really all about choice. It is because they are not really for choice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.