MacDailyNews - Where Mac news comes first

 MacDailyNews Poll

5 Day Most Commented

Opinion Archive

Current Headlines

Latest Joy of Tech

  • Latest Joy of Tech!

MacNN

AppleInsider

Macworld UK

TUAW

MacRumors

Yahoo! Finance AAPL

iTunes Top 10 Albums

Mac OS X Downloads

Mon, Dec 01, 2008 - 04:49 PM EST  —  AAPL: 88.93 (-3.74, -4.04%)  |  NASDAQ: 1398.07 (-137.50, -8.95%)

Wall Street Journal’s Mossberg: Free Microsoft program to battle spyware has serious flaws
Thursday, January 20, 2005 - 10:42 AM EST

"Microsoft, whose Windows operating system has been plagued by viruses, spyware and other security problems in recent years, last week began rolling out some free software to help users cope with those threats. The software giant introduced a 'beta,' or preliminary, version of a free product designed to block, detect and remove spyware. A free antivirus program is planned for later release," Walt Mossberg reports for The Wall Street Journal.

"Unfortunately, the company's first free security program has some serious flaws and lapses. I've been testing Microsoft's antispyware software, called simply Microsoft AntiSpyware, and I can't recommend it, in its present form, over the leading third-party antispyware program I have favored, Webroot's Spy Sweeper," Mossberg reports.

"Microsoft AntiSpyware does nothing at all to protect users of the rival Firefox Web browser from home- and search-page hijacking. It detects and corrects such hijacking only in its own Internet Explorer Web browser. The company says it is trying to focus on things that affect "the largest number of customers," and it notes that the vast majority of users rely on IE. But this... smacks of favoritism toward Microsoft products... It's good that Microsoft is finally offering users tools to protect their Windows computers. But it's going to have to do much better, and it's going to have to avoid the perception that it's using security as a tool to promote or favor its own products," Mossberg reports.

Full article here.

MacDailyNews Take: Was there some secret deal between the United States DOJ and Microsoft to resolve the anti trust case that stipulated that Microsoft would do absolutely nothing or just generally screw up for a specified period of time until competitors could balance things out a bit? Or is Microsoft just slowly collapsing from its own weight right before our eyes? Are you a Windows-only user? Get a Mac, it's much better. More info on how to add a safe, secure, powerful, and fun Mac OS X machine to your computing arsenal here.

MacDailyNews Note: Walt Mossberg is the author and creator of the weekly Personal Technology column in The Wall Street Journal, which has appeared every Thursday since 1991. Newsweek magazine calls Mr. Mossberg "the most powerful arbiter of consumer tastes in the computer world today." Time magazine calls him "the most influential computer journalist." And Rolling Stone calls him "the most powerful columnist in technology." The Washington Post declared Mr. Mossberg "one of the most powerful men in the high-tech world" and "a one-man media empire whose prose can launch a new product." And the New York Times calls him a "protean critic of the new economy's tools and toys." Mr. Mossberg was awarded the 1999 Loeb award for Commentary, the only technology writer to be so honored. For seven years in a row, 1995-2001, he was named as the most influential journalist writing about computers, in the annual ranking published by Technology Marketing magazine.

Related MacDailyNews articles:
Microsoft's 'free' protection scheme debuts in attempt to whack Windows malware - January 07, 2005

  • Social Web
  • E-mail






Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Reader Feedback: ( = registered)

Jan 20, 05 - 11:00 am Comment from: freebee

this does not surprise me.

Jan 20, 05 - 11:02 am Comment from: John

MDN, ya crack me up wink

Jan 20, 05 - 11:11 am Comment from: DavidO

re MDN's: "MacDailyNews Take: Was there some secret deal between the United States DOJ and Microsoft to resolve the anti trust case that stipulated that Microsoft would do absolutely nothing or just generally screw up for a specified period of time until competitors could balance things out a bit?"

What an awesome explanation. I'd assumed that the deal involved DOJ laying off Microsoft in return for campaign contributions to Republicans. But my thinking is just so very cynical and depressing. Even though my explanation is probably more accurate, MDN's is more fun. Much appreciated.

Jan 20, 05 - 11:21 am Comment from: Less is More

Whaddya expect? It was made by Microsoft.

Jan 20, 05 - 11:22 am Comment from: ndelc

If I were Bill, I'd sell my shares and disappear. Close the doors in Redmond and move on to a life of leisure. At some point, don't you think that guilt will have some effect on him? Maybe that's why he gives so much to charity?

Jan 20, 05 - 11:36 am Comment from: zzeed

smirk I don't want windows program even if it's free.

Jan 20, 05 - 11:43 am Comment from: Tommy Boy

Uhh guys? http://www.bbspot.com/News/2005/01/microsoft_antispyware.html

"Many Microsoft Windows users who downloaded the recently released AntiSpyware program from Microsoft, or had it installed through an automatic Windows update, woke up to a surprise. Unintentionally, the heuristics of the software detected Internet Explorer as spyware, and removed the program from their systems."

Jan 20, 05 - 12:19 pm Comment from: NoPCZone

The BEST answer is:

http://www.apple.com/macosx/

Jan 20, 05 - 12:20 pm Comment from: MacBuddy

ndelc,

[At some point, don't you think that guilt will have some effect on him?]

No. But, he does bring to mind that 'Gowan' song, 'Criminal Mind' wink


Tommy Boy,

Thanx, I'll be snickering at that all week!

-

'Window' is my magic word. Hee hee!

Jan 20, 05 - 12:34 pm Comment from: Eric

Holy Moly! And I recommened someone get it to try to fix their about:blank spyware problem. It was so weak, that the second she tried to install the MS product, about:blank went nuts and shut down the install.

Yeah, MS, you guys are on top of it.

Now, what did I do with my shotgun. My PC has sufffered enough...

Jan 20, 05 - 01:02 pm Comment from: erk

a band aid for a bigger problem (internet explorer)

Jan 20, 05 - 01:04 pm Comment from: Buffy

Its still a beta, give them a chance to screw up the actual release before we bash them

Jan 20, 05 - 01:10 pm Comment from: NoM$PlayerforYou!

Was there some secret deal between the United States DOJ and Microsoft to resolve the anti trust case...?

Yes there was, Microsoft has provided the US intelligence community with the best intelligence coup of the last 20+ years.

M$ wishes to continue this trend by controling all spyware that's not it's own.

I know of two instances where the US Military black ops have hacked local buisnesses computers running M$ Windows to check on spy equipment inventories before the invasion of Grenada.

I speak no lies.

Jan 20, 05 - 01:13 pm Comment from: retro cat

So let me get this straight.

Microsoft creates a crappy product so riddled with flaws and bloat that an entire industry of hackers is created.

And they reward themselves by making money selling programs to protect people because of their flawed product?

Do they have absolutely no morals or sense of right or wrong?

Jan 20, 05 - 01:26 pm Comment from: solarflare

Mossberg had his head in Jobs' ass since decades.

Jan 20, 05 - 01:29 pm Comment from: anon

Retro cat - one assumes your question about MS having no morals or not knowing right from wrong is clearly rhetorical.

All proven - they steal ideas and code, cheat in business dealings, monopolise (thus driving others out of business)... this shows they have pretty low morals already. Why not try to make money from their own poorly written software?

Nice work if you can get it.

Jan 20, 05 - 01:48 pm Comment from: Mac User

If buying MS anti-spyware/virii software to fix problems created by Windows' crappy security architecture isn't the most blatant case of Stockholm syndrome, I don't know what is.
It's one thing to be in denial about M$' weak OS, but it's just amazing to pay M$ to fix the holes they left open in their own software. And they call us fanboys!?!

Jan 20, 05 - 02:07 pm Comment from: treadlightly

Actually, what's really funny is that MS Antispyware labels ITSELF as spyware. See it at http://chris.pirillo.com/blog/_archives/2005/1/6/233293.html, and make sure you check out the screen shots.

Jan 20, 05 - 02:23 pm Comment from: NoMacForYou

I havent had any issues with it...Infact, I think the Beta is better than most antispyware programs that have been out for awhile..Mossberg is a bitch.

Jan 20, 05 - 02:51 pm Comment from: John

So let's see. The antispyware only protects microsoft software. So everything else is fair game and your system is really unprotected!
What a bunch of crap! I want a protection scheme that protects the whole computer not just one little piece of it.

Keep it up Microsoft and you will find yourself all alone.

Jan 20, 05 - 03:38 pm Comment from: mac dood

"........I havent had any issues with it...Infact, I think the Beta is better than most antispyware programs that have been out for awhile.."

NoMacForYou...

You seem to post here often enough, but it seems you stilldont get it ...do you ?

The point is...WHY should you HAVE to put up with having to use anti-spyware, anti-popup, anti-virus ... or any other anti- malware programs .... free..or otherwise ??

If you'd just take the time to remove your head from Bill Gates' nether regions ... maybe you could understand that by using a Mac and OSX ... you could free your mind ..(not to mention your computer) .. of such things...

*looks skyward* .... (you give them eyes, and yet they still cannot see !)

Jan 20, 05 - 04:06 pm Comment from: Jack A

You know they are only offering it free for now. Once they get enough people dependent on it they will start charging. What a racket! Create the problem then sell the solution. Reminds me of those pop up windows about software for blocking pop up windows I have heard about.

Jan 20, 05 - 05:00 pm Comment from: NoMacForYou

Mac Dood: I do use a Mac man. But I have users. These users would die before switching to a mac (Dont ask why) and IE does get all fsckd up after awhile of surfing to places you shouldnt be. It doesnt hurt to have an application like this. At work I use a mac. At home I use a PC and after doing so for over 10 yrs now, I still havent had viruses and so on infecting my personal systems. Why? Because I dont load gator, gain, kazaa, morpheus, and all of the BS that comes along with (). I'm willing to bet that if PC users were a little more informed about security and surfing, we wouldnt be having this conversation. Last time I checked not even OS X (Security through Obscurity) is completely secure..So until GOD comes down and makes an OS completely secure, quite trying to get people to switch who are perfectly comfortable with what they own..You guys are starting to sound like MLM salesmen.

PS: having my head up Bills Ass doesnt change the fact that you have yours up steves (BUT HIS SHIT DON'T STINK RIGHT?) You use what you want, I use what I want at home (I have to use a mac at work). Its a matter of preferences, Some people are too stupid to use a PC and need a Mac to feel better about their computing experience. Me, I need a computer I can change the hardware in and have it "Just Work" and So far in these yrs of using the architecture and OS, Im happy with what I have. The difference.

You get a Pre-Fabbed system that is stable and "secure" out of the box.

I get a system that does the same thing, But I must assemble it myself.

I dont think you get it.

Here you have Apple that closely monitors and creates their own hardware (Which is mostly made of PC hardware) and builds the OS around that.

With MS Windows, You get 1 million different hardware makers building around on common model. I like the choice of hardware that I get because I benefit from capability of building up a system over time.

I think it all boils down to one thing. and thats what you need to figure out.

JAck A: Wishful thinking man, but theyy wont charge for it.

Jan 20, 05 - 05:01 pm Comment from: Clocker

The only program that removes all Windows malware:

C:\>fdisk

Brought to you by the Magic Word "trouble". As in "MicroSoft is in trouble."

Jan 20, 05 - 05:53 pm Comment from: BuriedCaesar

NoMacForYou,

You say "they won't charge for it" with some air of authority and knowledge. Are you absolutely SURE that M$ will NEVER charge for this "program"? They themselves have never said that, have they? Correct me if I'm wrong, please.

Jan 20, 05 - 06:31 pm Comment from: Qman

NoMacForYou....

You listed some the popular sites and programs that use Microsoft's built-in exploits - amd you mention that users should be more informed when surfing. Hell, Micorsoft uses those exploits in their own software. (Do you have kids, especially teenagers? There are millions out there who sign on that stuff everyday. So, should we now yell at the parents, who let them do this?)

I can go to my local Sunday flea market and buy a used PC for $150 and hook it up to the web. That seller is not going to warn me about using an unprotected computer - he only wants his money.

It was only after tens of thousands of viruses has Microsoft finally gone public, and started issuing public warnings. Yes, they have had their "updates" but those uninformed users were sold on the fact that their computers were already "stable and safe".

Jan 20, 05 - 08:47 pm Comment from: mac dood

".....These users would die before switching to a mac (Dont ask why) and IE does get all fsckd up after awhile of surfing ....."

So what youre saying is... Billys own browser is the problem ??
That would be a good "Reason #1 to switch, wouldnt it ?

".....Because I dont load gator, gain, kazaa, morpheus, and all of the BS that comes along with...."

Gee.... with a Mac... you wouldnt have to worry what
programs you run, doesnt matter ... if it runs on a Mac... no malware !!
This would be a good Reason #2 to switch...wouldnt it ??

"..... need a computer I can change the hardware in and have it "Just Work" ....."

I change hardware in a variety of Macs.... effortlessly, and seamlessly..
all the time ....and it ALWAYS .... "Just Works" ... Ive often found that with Macs... its always "Plug & Play"... but with WinTel boxes ... its always more like "Plug & Pray" ...
A good Reason #3 to switch ..

".....You get a Pre-Fabbed system that is stable and "secure" out of the box.
I get a system that does the same thing, But I must assemble it myself...."


The words "WinDoze" and "Secure" should NEVER be used in the same sentense !! ... This is just too funny !! .. and...
a GOOD Reason #4 to switch

NoMacForYou...

Without even realizing it.... you have given the world (at least) .. FOUR .. good reasons to be using Macs and OSX ...

If you are so unhappy using a Mac at work ..... why not ask your boss for a Dull ... or a Gateway or something....??
When it gets bogged down with all the malware you certainly will aquire .... he might notice your productivity has fallen off, due to the time(s) you'll be spending "de-lousing" that PeeCee ... instead of actually working !!

Youre a funny guy.... ya kno ??

Have you ever thought of doing Stand Up ??

LOL

Jan 20, 05 - 09:24 pm Comment from: Mac Yak

I had to reboot my Dull at work 3 times today. 24 minutes of productivity down the tubes.

The only time I've rebooted this G3 PowerBook is to install things. I've had it exactly one year today... which happens to be the 21st birthday of the Macintosh!

HAPPY BIRTHDAY, MAC!

Reader feedback page 1 of 1 pages:

Always -- Free ground shipping with orders over $50 at the Apple Store.

Add Your Feedback:

Register or Login

Name:

Email: (optional)

Emoticons | Allowed HTML Tags

Remember my personal information   Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the "MDN Magic Word" you see in the image below: