BusinessWeek: Why Greenpeace repeatedly makes flawed attacks on Apple

“There Greenpeace goes again,” Arik Hesseldahl writes for BusinessWeek. “First it was the Mac. Now it’s the iPhone. I’ve harrumphed before, in this column and in my blog, about Greenpeace’s flawed attacks on Apple for using certain toxic chemicals in its computers. And now I’m ready to harrumph anew.”

“It’s not that Apple’s environmental conscience should be entirely clean. The company is in no better shape than other major computer makers when it comes to the use of these chemicals. Yet while it’s not an excuse, Apple sells just a fraction of the number of computers sold by Dell and Hewlett-Packard, both of which draw less consistent ire from Greenpeace,” Hesseldahl writes.

“It’s clear why Greenpeace picks on Apple so incessantly: The unique place that Apple and its chief executive officer, Steve Jobs occupy within popular culture and the technology industry make them both convenient whipping boys for publicity-hungry environmental organizations. Calling out Apple over environmental issues simply gets more headlines than criticizing HP would,” Hesseldahl writes.

“And Apple makes an especially juicy target when you consider that its branding and identity tend to overlap with so many cultural touchstones that the modern, left-leaning consumer is likely to consider important. Demographically speaking, Mac users are more likely to care about global warming, deforestation, and other environmental issues than your average Windows user. They’re also more likely to respond to one of Greenpeace’s calls to write letters, send e-mail, and show up at shareholder meetings to lobby for whatever the organization is up in arms about at any given moment. And having Al Gore, a freshly-minted Nobel laureate, on its board of directors also sends a strong message about how Apple wants to be perceived on the environmental front,” Hesseldahl writes.

Much more in the full article here.

43 Comments

  1. I’m an environmentalist, but Greenpeace is starting to tick me off big time. They are making enemies of the exact people they want to get support from.

    They need to address BIGGER companies who’s “footprint” is more damaging than Apple’s.

  2. Spotted owl? Yum, Try clay-baked hedgehog! Seriously, you could make fruits-of-the-hedgerow jelly and get brownie points at your local produce show.

    As for Greenpeace, well I used to belong until I wearied of their publicity-hungry ways. A shame because much of their message seems OK, but the way they carry on makes you wanna vom.

  3. I don’t think Macintosh owner are more concerned about “global warming, deforestation, and other environmental issues”. Don’t think that I believe they are less concerned.

    There has been this idea that Macintosh users are more “red” than “blue”. There is no basis for it.

    I would bet that P.E.T.A and Greenpeace both have offices full of PCs.

  4. Key words here are “more likely to care”. I could give a purple fuck about this so-called global warming. I think it’s a bunch of horse shit. Besides, sometimes it’s too cold anyway. I believe in the cyclical temperature bit. Warming and cooling trends. Besides, by the time the world warms to an extent that would matter much to me, I’ll be pushing up daisies so fuck you Greenpeace.

  5. The M-O
    Have you noticed how much Spotted Owls taste like California Condors?
    You also get more meat with the Condors.

    And to the Democrats, the ultra-libs are killing your once great party.

    When Bill Clinton and Bill Maher can’t even speak without the loonies childish rants blaring, then it’s time to distance yourselves.

    Just some honest, friendly advice from the right. (about the Condors….)

  6. For the last twenty years I’ve given Greenpeace money, but I emailed them about a week ago to tell them they would no longer be receiving donations from me.

    I’d have no trouble with Greenpeace going after the entire computer industry, but to single out Apple? It amounts to enivronmental pandering.

  7. Big dirty business is winning this one, Greenpeace was a thorn in their side so they set about emasculating it. The infiltration took a few years but clearly they are comfortable with their power so they have set about discrediting Greenpeace. These stories about Apple are so farcical that they have the qualities of spoofs, it is clear that there is a hidden agenda.

    If anyone doubts this compare with the actions of Microsoft, they have recently be caught out infiltrating international standards organizations to get their junk approved, there was the recent story on MDN about how they infiltrated the BBC to get their way with iPlayer. Don’t believe that such dirty tricks are restricted to the software industry, most every industry has its rogue players. The prize is selling shit for loads of money and some people are just incurably greedy.

    Time to move on, found a new organization to represent the ideals. Better still do what is best in your own life and encourage people around you to do the same.

  8. the extreme wings of both parties should be taken off the endangered list…

    a nut is a nut, pandering to special interests is incredibly destructive, and there are no excuses for bad policy making… cause we all lose.

    by the way… OSX ROCKS!

  9. I’m with Marco.

    Extremists in BOTH parties make me sick. Over the top for their causes Right or Left wing extremists are ruining this country.

    Politicians are more concerned about not angering any extremist votes than doing what’s best for the country as a whole.

    Most of us lie somewhere in the logical middle ground.

    HA HA–MDN magic word = “center”

  10. @opie –

    If you could actually spell the words you’re trying to use I’d be more inclined to not think you’re not engaging in satire.

    But, just in case you’re serious, you should note that the Republicans of Abe Lincoln and Ike are not the same as the Republicans of Tricky Dick Nixon, Ronald Reagan and George Bush. And the Democrats of the 1870’s (a bunch of backwards southern hicks) are not the Democrats of FDR and JFK and Bill Clinton. The backwards southern hicks all went Republican when the Democrats backet the civil rights movement in the 1960s.

  11. The writer of propaganda on the board should be fired, as it has been shown by a British court that the man’s book has major untruths in it, and so schools in the U.K are not to use it without pointing out the lies in it.
    As an Apple shareholder, I would feel much more comfortable if Al jumped off the board and ran for president. BTW, in the Canadian legal system, Greenpeace would have to pay court costs for both parties in a civil suit if it lost its case, but it appears there is no downside in the U.S. for launching frivolous suits.

  12. Anyone who cites World Nutcase Daily as some kind of objective source needs to be regarded with a great deal of skepticism.

    And as much as the right loves to fetishize Reagan, he was NOT in the mold of Lincoln.

    Can we get back to talking about Macs, please?

  13. @TowerTone –

    You confirm my hypothesis. Prior to the passage of the Civil Rights Act, the Republican Party was capable of working for the greater good of individual citizens. After Tricky Dick and Reagan infected the party with the lust for power above all else, they used implicit racism (we’re NOT Democrats) to attract the disaffected Dixiecrats to the Republican Party and made enough hollow promises to them to get them to vote against their economic interests and bring the Republican party to power.

    If you think Regan was cut from the same cloth as Lincoln, you need to read and think while you’re not sipping the kool-aid. Regan only stands our as a beacon when viewed from the shadows of the Bush administration. Reagan was just a good actor who could stand where he was told and stick to the script.

  14. Hey, save the planet by polluting, chain-sawing all the trees, and filling the air with smog so thick you could cut it with a dull butter knife. Reason- all the people will die, animals, and it can start a new life in a million years with clear blue skies and water.

    Other wise it is not: save the planet, but save the people that depend on this planet…. Greenpeace is ass backwards!

  15. @lurker

    Never said they (the Republicans) were the same just thought it was interesting reading that should be mandatory. Did you know that a tigers skin is also striped? Makes sense to me that a leopard can never ever really changes it’s spots. As Col. Klink would say, “Very, very interesting.” As far as the Dems they are not the same. They are a little too socialistic for my taste. Kind of like MicroSoft. It doesn’t work and it will never change

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.